UPDATED: 94,341 jobs 'not really created or saved' by the stimulus (and counting)
By: David Freddoso and Mark Hemingway
Washington Examiner
November 12, 2009
View Bogus jobs 'created or saved' by the Stimulus in a larger map
12/22/09
With the revelation that CalTrans dramatically over-reported the number of jobs created or saved with stimulus money, we've added hundreds more to our job count.
12/15/09
We've added hundreds more jobs that weren't really created or saved from new media reports and further analysis of Recovery.gov data.
12/1/09 UPDATE:
Roughly 2,000 new imaginary stimulus jobs have been added to the map, including hundreds of reported Head Start jobs that were actually just pay raises.
11/26/09 UPDATE:
We've added more than 100 jobs that were "created or saved" with impossibly small amounts of money.
11/24/09 UPDATE:
California's stimulus audit has found a massive overcount of more than 13,000 corrections jobs supposedly "saved."
11/19 UPDATE:
We've added thousands more jobs in several dozen cities to our not really "created or saved" stimulus jobs map. The total number of jobs we have found to be "not really created or saved" now approaches 80,000. Several new states and the Territory of Guam have new entries. We will continue updating the map in the coming weeks.
Most of the new pins on our interactive map represent such un-started, un-funded contracts, according to data taken from Recovery.gov. Because the Obama administration has been using its inflated claim of 640,000 jobs "created or saved" to make projections for future stimulus job creation, these un-started, un-funded projects really should not be part of the total. Moreover, the administration itself has asked contractors not to make "projections" but to report jobs as they are "created or saved," according to news reports.
More than ten percent of the jobs the Obama administration has claimed were "created or saved" by the $787 billion stimulus package are doubtful or imaginary, according to reports compiled from eleven major newspapers and the Associated Press.
Based only on our analysis of stimulus media coverage in the last two weeks, The Examiner has created this interactive map to document exaggerated stimulus claims. The map, which will be updated as new revelations appear, currently reflects an exaggeration by the Obama administration of about 75,000 jobs, out of the 640,000 jobs supposedly "created or saved."
The map reflects reports from The Wall Street Journal, The Boston Globe, the Sacramento Bee, The New York Times, USA Today, the Las Vegas Sun, the Detroit Free Press, the New York Post, the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel, the Associated Press, the Chicago Tribune, and the Atlanta Journal-Constitution. It remains a work in progress because relatively few newspapers have scrutinized stimulus spending so far.
The Obama administration has claimed that the $787 billion economic stimulus package "saved or created" some 650,000 jobs. But almost as soon as the White House trotted out this figure, news organizations found huge exaggerations in the reported data. Many of the jobs reportedly created do not exist or cannot be accounted for.
UPDATE: Today's report from ABC News tells us that prior to releasing its jobs report, the administration cut out 60,000 additional jobs from unreliable reports, none of which appear to overlap with the ones we've highlighted here. Had those jobs been included in the original count, the number of jobs "created or saved" by the stimulus would have exceeded 700,000, and the number of imaginary or doubtful jobs would have approached 20 percent.
More from David Freddoso
More from Mark Hemingway
- Controversial National Labor Relations Board nominee Craig Becker shot down in Senate
- Will Dems try and slip card check legislation into upcoming jobs bill?
- Bloomberg obit headline calls Murtha 'Supporter of Troops'?
- Democratic Senator Ben Nelson to filibuster key nominee favored by Big Labor
- White House wants to make filibuster a campaign issue?
