Opinion

[Print]  [Email]        

Blowing Smoke on State Climate Action Plans

By: Examiner Editorial
-
December 28, 2008

Many states have adopted Climate Action Plans (CAPs) that limit greenhouse gases by 2020, and nearly identical plans are advancing rapidly toward approval in other states.
But according to a peer-reviewed study of the Maryland CAP by the Beacon Hill Institute at Suffolk University in Massachusetts - an economics think tank - these cookie-cutter proposals are “seriously flawed” for multiple reasons. If implemented, the plans could take other states down the same road California is already traveling. Anti-business policies that were often justified mainly on environmental grounds, have cost Californians dearly. Millions of jobs fled to lower tax neighbors  like Nevada and Arizona, the state’s 8.4 percent unemployment rate rivals Michigan’s, and political gridlock over a $40 billion budget deficit could leave California bankrupt early in 2009.

California’s carbon emissions rules are the toughest in the nation, and are often touted as a model for other states and the federal government. But Californians will soon begin paying even more for electricity, natural gas, and water, thanks to carbon taxes. These costs will supposedly be offset by a new clean-energy economy that will create “green” jobs and add $78 billion to the state economy. If that sounds familiar, it should because it’s the same scenario touted by President-elect Barack Obama for the nation.

The Beacon Hill analysis notes that Maryland generates less than half of one percent of the world’s carbon emissions, so nothing the state does will have any discernable effect on global climate. Therefore, “no measurable benefit” can be quantified. But the downsides of the Maryland CAP are all-too-concrete. For starters, the plan (and others like it) “fails to perform the most basic task of any cost-benefit analysis - quantifying costs and benefits in monetary terms so they can be directly compared.” The plan contains 42 recommendations to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 2020, and claims it will create hundreds of thousands of new “green jobs” and a $16 billion boost to Maryland’s GDP.

The Maryland’s CAP fails to explain how all those new “green” jobs will outweigh the loss of existing jobs in industries forced to reduce output. As Beacon Hill points out, if increased conservation efforts could really save companies billions of dollars, they’d already be doing it voluntarily. The plan also fails to take into account the loss of goods and services that won’t be produced in order to meet mandatory energy reduction targets starting next year. Instead, as it does with jobs, the CAP model “counts forgone energy consumption as a benefit” – when in fact it is an energy tax. Caveat emptor.

For more information on the flaws in many CAPs - and the common organization and funding behind them - check out Climate Strategies Watch.



Most Popular Headlines


To view this site, you need to have Flash Player 8.0 or later installed. Click here to get the latest Flash player.


 


 



 

Reader Comments

All comments on this page are subject to our Terms of Use and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Examiner or its staff.

Robert G.

Dec 29, 2008

If it says "global warming" or "climate change" on the label DON'T TRUST IT! GW is a scam and it is only leading to more scams and bad ideas. The earth's natural cycle of warming and cooling is now going into a cooing cycle and is exposing Al Gore for the scam artiest he is.

 

thomas

Jan 1, 2009

I think the real downside is that they won't show the actual scientific reports and data justifying cap at all. We have no idea what methodology was used (if any). However, the reports and data ARE available from research facilities that disprove global warming. "Green" is a moronic idea, just another way to steal our money through taxes. Show the reports/data and, after reviewing it, I'll believe it.

 


Post a comment


Email:
(This will not be displayed or shared. Privacy Policy)

Display Name:

Comment:




Sports

Giants 9, Padres 3

San Diego #####@ # San Francisco... Full story

Economy

India's Infosys says quarterly profit up 1.6 pct, but warns of steep revenue drop

Indian outsourcing bellwether Infosys Technologies Ltd. reported a slight rise in quarterly profit in dollar terms but warned of a steep drop in revenue as its global clients struggle to cope with the economic slowdown. Full story

Entertainment

Judge temporarily bans release of sex tape starring 'Real Housewives of New Jersey' woman

One of the stars of Bravo's television series "Real Housewives of New Jersey" went to court Wednesday to avoid getting a little more exposure than she wanted. Full story