Opinion

[Print]  [Email]        

Iran, N. Korea Send Wake-up Calls for Missile Defense

By: James Carafano, Examiner Columnist
-
February 8, 2009

KEY DATA
    * Ten years ago, only six nations had nuclear weapons states.  Today, there are nine.
    * Twenty-eight countries now have ballistic missiles.
    * Iran's satellite launching last week shows they are close to developing a long-range intercontinental ballistic missile.
    * The U.S. missile defense system currently consists of 24 ground-based interceptors deployed in Alaska and California.

TAKE HOME
    * The U.S. began developing a defense against nuclear missiles following President Ronald Reagan's March 1983 "Star Wars" speech.
    * Today America can, indeed, “hit a bullet with a bullet." Since 2001, 37 of our 47 “Hit-to-Kill” missile defense tests have been successful.

“I think I screwed up.” - President Barack Obama on the Daschle nomination.

The crash-and-burn of Tom Daschle’s nomination to head the Health and Human Services Department wasn’t the first bad news to hit the new administration. Nor will it be the last.

Many in the media depicted Daschle’s fall from grace as a disaster for the president.  But this episode is really no more than an unsettling blip.  It reveals little about how President Obama will handle the great challenges of the day.

Presidential mettle can only be measured by serious trials that test character and leadership.  President Obama will face plenty of real challenges over the next four years, and we'll know them when we see them. Odds are they’ll start arriving faster than he wants—or expects.

The White House has tried to look like it’s moving fast on many problem areas.  In less than two weeks Obama had: announced plans to close Guantanamo Bay and other terrorist detention facilities; vowed to solve global warming, and appointed czars for global problems ranging from cyber threats to Middle East conflicts.

Yet the administration has shown little interest in actually driving the world agenda. In the real hot spots—like Iraq, Afghanistan, and Pakistan—Obama’s policies look an awful lot like Bush policies. Elsewhere, the administration has signaled only an interest in “dialogue”—the diplomatic equivalent of “let’s do lunch.”

This is understandable.  Like all presidents, Obama wants to focus on his domestic agenda for the “first hundred days.”  But passive global leadership cedes the initiative to others, and some of those “others” are more than happy to drive the agenda in ways that can create real crises.

No issue carries greater potential for crisis than the growing threat of missile attack. Last week, Iran launched its first homemade satellite into space. Foreign Ministry spokesman Hassan Qashqavi assured an alarmed world that “Iran’s space advancement serves no military purpose.”

He is probably right… today.  But Americans should be worried today, for the same reason they worried when the Soviets launched Sputnik in 1957:  the launch demonstrates the increasing sophistication of a hostile nation’s ballistic missile program.

Layer that on top of Iran’s rapidly progressing nuclear program (which they also claim has no military purpose), and you have to wonder when Iran will drop the other shoe—a “surprise” test of its first nuclear weapon.

North Korea hasn’t been quiet either. Pyongyang has just abrogated a bunch of agreements with the South, and media reports indicate a new long-range missile site is 80 percent complete, with another round of missile tests imminent.

It may be only saber-rattling intended to cow the leaders in Seoul.  With Kim Jong-Il, you never know…And that’s the problem.

Also troubling, though, are the administration’s early signals on missile defense.  It said nothing when Sen. Carl Levin, D-MI, declared, “We are going to cut weapons systems” and singled out the missile-defense program.

Also worrisome, some of the newbies have suggested they might try to make nice with the Russians by reneging on our commitment to build missile defenses in Europe.

The surest way for the administration to set itself up for a colossal crisis is to abandon missile defense. To do so in the face of provocative actions by tinhorn tyrants in Iran and North Korea—or in response to mere complaints from Russia—is to look weak and inept.  And that would invite disaster.

To paraphrase Lt. Gen. Henry “Trey” Obering, the recently retired director of the Missile Defense Agency:  “When all else fails—when all the negotiations have broken down—you must be able to destroy a missile in the air.  Otherwise, all you can do is apologize to those who died.”

In matters of life-and-death import, like missile defense, “I screwed up” won’t cut it.

Examiner columnist James Carafano is senior research fellow for national security studies at The Heritage Foundation (heritage.org).



beltway confidential

In a brief op-ed in USA Today, White House counterterrorism chief John Brennan charges that critics who question the Obama administration's decision to grant Miranda rights to...

Wall Street Journal -- Leverage Sought In Health Summit Republicans are asking President Obama to make a show of good faith before his proposed health care summit by publicly...

Sen. Jim DeMint, R-S.C., sends word by e-mail of a Marco Rubio moneybomb tomorrow, to celebrate the anniversary of President Obama's hug with Rubio's opponent for the GOP Senate...

In a television interview this afternoon, Democratic Tennessee Rep. Steve Cohen pronounced judgment on the doctors who were operating on Rep. Jack Murtha, D-Pa., when he died....






Most Popular Headlines





To view this site, you need to have Flash Player 8.0 or later installed. Click here to get the latest Flash player.


 


 



 

Reader Comments

All comments on this page are subject to our Terms of Use and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Examiner or its staff. Comment box is limited to 250 words.

USN

Feb 9, 2009

You incorrectly stated the current US Ballistic Missile Defence capability by omitting the US Navy's role in BMD. The USN has the responsibility of defending against short to medium range ballistic missiles and is ten for twelve in their BMD exercises.

 

USN

Feb 9, 2009

You incorrectly stated the current US Ballistic Missile Defense capability by omitting the US navy's role. The USN's capability and respoinsibility is in defending the US and it's friends against the short to medium range ballistic missile threats. The USN is 10 for 12 in their test events.

 

James Jay Carafano

Feb 9, 2009

Fair point. I did not mention the advances in the Navy's sea-based system. Primarily, because this system seems to be enjoying broad support in the administration and the Congress. The limitations of sea-based is that it can't cover everything that needs to be protected. So while we need to continue to move forward with sea-based defenses, an excellent system, we need to move on other fronts as well.

 

MDA

Feb 9, 2009

The sea-based missile defense element is a fully integrated part of the missile defense system. It is managed and funded by the Missile Defense Agency. The sea-based tests are included in the 37 of 47.

 

Don Shields

Feb 11, 2009

The best delivery system will be a dedicated man in a van. 100% accuracy. Ten of those in various city centers at the same time will cause incalculable damage while any retaliation will have to await prolonged investigation

 


Post a comment


Email:
(This will not be displayed or shared. Privacy Policy)

Your Name:

Comment:




Local

Slideshow: Washington area snow photos

Here are some of the best snow photos in the DC area from the Associated Press, the Examiner' s own Andrew Harnik and courtesy photos from Kathleen Dellinger: Full story

Politics

Rep. John Murtha dies at 77

A spokesman says Democratic Rep. John Murtha of... Full story

Local

D.C. region braces for up to 20 more inches of snow

The National Weather Service has the entire D.C. metro area, from Prince William County north, under a winter storm warning for 10 to 20 inches of snow. Forecasters have had their eyes on this storm for days, but the projected snow totals were bumped up late Monday. Full story