Opinion

[Print]  [Email]        

The Pelosi Doctrine: What’s good for her is good for the U.S.

Examiner Editorial
-
January 5, 2009

President-elect Barack Obama meets today with Democratic congressional leaders to discuss their forthcoming economic stimulus package. On Wednesday a Democrats-only committee hearing will convene to push for congressional action before Obama’s January 20 inauguration. Thus advances a sham economic stimulus bill via a sham legislative process.

Regardless whether the final version spends $750 billion or some figure north of $1 trillion, the measure will be an economic sham. First, if the bill is paid with a blizzard of freshly printed greenbacks, it will invariably lead to galloping inflation, which, of course,  destroys everybody’s wealth. If the funds are borrowed, the government will not only be setting the stage for inflation, but it will also be increasing the national debt and constricting credit. Second, as multiple studies have shown, government spending has little stimulative value. One of those studies was done by Obama’s new chief economic advisor, Christina Romer of UC Berkeley, who found $3 in increased Gross Domestic Product (GDP) for every $1 in tax cuts. Increased spending generates at best a mere 40 cents of GDP growth on the dollar. Third, that 40 cents actually goes to special interests like labor unions, politically influential contractors in favored industries and state and local political allies of the party in power. Odds are Obama will eventually rue the day he signed off on this sham.

Then there is sham legislative process being used by House Speaker Nancy Pelosi to ramrod the measure through the 111th Congress, with its strengthened Democratic majorities in both chambers. The stimulus package will be the focus of a Wednesday hearing of the House Steering and Policy Committee, co-chaired by Rep. George Miller, D-CA, and Rosa DeLauro, D-CN. This all-Democrat panel has no legislative authority but will hear from witnesses who will mostly extol government spending. The hearing will also be a focal point for the plague of special interests who have been lobbying for weeks to get a piece of the pie. Officially, Pelosi says “this hearing will build upon the stimulus package the House passed in September and the numerous hearings held by our other committees.” She adds that “our economy demands Congress act quickly to pass at the earliest date an economic recovery plan to provide immediate relief to Americans and to create or save millions of American jobs.” In other words, forget the too-slow normal legislative process which includes Republicans. If speed is the issue, why not just let Pelosi issue an economic stimulus edict and be done with those pesky elections for good? After all, if it’s good by Pelosi, it’s good for America, right?



beltway confidential

Every so often a sentence you read in a news story catches your eye. Consider this sentence in a November 6 Washington Post story headlined, “Environmental groups at odds...

The words of Maj. Nidal Malik Hasan, a few hours before authorities say he opened fire on fellow soldiers at Ft. Hood, Texas, killing 13 and wounding 29. The Washington Post...

Scarcely more than an hour after the House narrowly passed the Democrats' health care legislation Saturday night, President Obama sent out a fundraising email asking supporters...

Based on the House vote on health care, which seats are possible pick-ups for Republicans? One place to look would be seats in districts where Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz.,...


Most Popular Headlines



To view this site, you need to have Flash Player 8.0 or later installed. Click here to get the latest Flash player.


 


 



 

Reader Comments

All comments on this page are subject to our Terms of Use and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Examiner or its staff. Comment box is limited to 250 words.

Richard (of Whittier)

Jan 5, 2009

It's like the bumber stcker on my car says: "Hey Congress" You Suck ! nothing says it better.........

 

Matthew C

Jan 5, 2009

Rosa DeLauro is a wonderful woman. She represents Connecticut (CT) and not Canada (CN). You should really try and get the states straight...there are only 50 you know.

 

Matthew C

Jan 5, 2009

Rosa DeLauro is a wonderful woman. She represents Connecticut (CT) and not Canada (CN). You should really try and get the states straight...there are only 50 you know.

 

Phil Mause

Jan 5, 2009

So - what do you suggest we do instead? Doing nothing doesn't seem to be working very well. Herbert Hoover gave it a try. If we wait until unemployment get to 20 percent, we will see a politcal reaction that will threaten our market system. The Democrats are just trying to save capitalism from itself.

 

mark

Jan 5, 2009

PHIL ... Did you read the post? Tax cuts are a more efficient stimulus to the economy, and less corrupting.

 

Patrick

Jan 5, 2009

To Phil Mause: Herbert Hoover did nothing? Wow, I cannot imagine a more historically inaccurate thought. Please do research. Ever heard of the Smoot-Hawley Tariff??? Wow, our brainwashing government teachers have done an excellent job of washing away history. Hoover and FDR gave us too much involvement. Please do research. You couldn;t be more ignorant on Herbert Hoover.

 

Mike McElravy

Jan 5, 2009

It isn't that Hoover didn't do anything. The problem was that what he did was wrong. Protectionist measures and a tax increase during an economic downturn is today almost universally regarded as folly.

 

RightWingConspiracy

Jan 5, 2009

> Doing nothing doesn't seem to be working very well. Herbert Hoover gave it a try.< Phil, you are a dunce. The cornerstone of Hoover's Depression policies was protectionist trade legislation, which BO seems to favor, although it's never an easy thing to pin him down on a position. Further, as the anondyne to Hoover's failure to lift the economy, FDR also did exactly what BO is planning to do. Unfortunately, according to two UCLA economists, FDR's policies prolonged teh Great Depression for seven years. See: http://newsroom.ucla.edu/portal/ucla/FDR-s-Policies-Prolonged-Depression-5409.aspx?RelNum=5409 I hope you people knew what you were doing when you put a socialist in the White House.

 

Dishman

Jan 5, 2009

I seriously doubt anyone, including Pelosi, knows what Congress is actually going to do. Does anyone know what Congress is going to do? Probably not. Do you personally feel any certainty regarding what Congress is going to do? Probably not. What do you personally do when you're uncertain regarding what is about to happen? Most people try to avoid making serious commitments, and retreat to relative safety, away from the uncertainty. This continued talk of Congressional action is, in and of itself, increasing the uncertainty and pushing people away from risk-taking. This conversation is killing us.

 

Harry

Jan 5, 2009

Matthew - CN is China. Canada is CA. You should really try and get the countries straight...there are only 239 you know.

 

DavidN

Jan 5, 2009

The funniest part of this is that none of the Democrats apparently want to do this stimulus package to end the depression. Rahm Emmanuel has been quoted as saying that they don't want to "miss this opportunity". What this means is simple: creeping governmental control of everything can take a giant leap forward, because people will accept it while the economy's bad. It will ostensibly be to heal our economic woes: in actual point of fact, it's intended to extend government control of everything.

 

Alex

Jan 5, 2009

You don't acknowledge that somewhere around half of the Obama stimulus package is found in tax cuts...which you laud as the true answer for economic stimulus.

 

JWnTX

Jan 5, 2009

When a company (or industry, for that matter) is run by shoddy management, you can bet there's more efficient management champing at the bit to take over. This propping up of shoddy management is nothing but a reward for the Ivy Leaguers who've proven--once again--that they have no concept of how to run a real business (or government). Some way, some how, we're going to have to dismantle this bureaucracy if we're going to continue to live as free men. The tipping point is close...

 

comatus

Jan 5, 2009

Harry, CN is also Canadian National. Since (ADM), (USX), and (UAW) have already been used as congressional identifiers, I just assumed another of the "new parties" had been heard from...

 

Jan 5, 2009

Nancy "let 'em eat cake" Pelosi is even more of a fool than Obama. The best thing for this country would be to build a fence around DC and turn it into a federal prison given most are crooks. These are the very people that caused the economic mess and make it worse with every move they make.

 

Phil Mause

Jan 5, 2009

Fair enough. Hoover did some things - the Reconstruction Finance Corporation, the tariff; but then he tried to balance the budget. The economy needs countercyclical spending to increase aggregate demand - economics 101. When the New Deal engaged in this kind of spending, the depression eased. When they tried to balance the budget and tighten the money supply in 1937-38, the depression came back. The stimulus can be in the form of tax cuts or spending or a combination of the two but it has to be fast - the longer we wait, the bigger it will have to be. And this time we may not have World War 2 waiting in the wings to solve the problem for us. It is easier to criticize a proposed solution than to come up with a viable alternative. So - I am back to my original question - what would you do? Nothing? I guess we have established that that is even less than what Herbert Hoover did. Phil Mause

 

joe

Jan 5, 2009

"sit around and do nothing"? Oh, that's a problem now? Seems that's what the Dems demanded when Bush tried to fix Social Security. "Save capitalism from itself"? How bout save us from Dodd and Frank!

 

Romeyn

Jan 5, 2009

Republican mantra: "bailouts for the rich, i.e. CEOs and the banks, capitalism for everyone else." And NO, the big three car manufacturers are not getting a bailout, just a loan. Ya know, THE KIND YOU PAY BACK! Didn't Bush start this bailout plan, or am I mistaken, OF COURSE, it was the democrats... please.

 

Dr. Fred in PA

Jan 6, 2009

Dear Phil: I have some novel ideas. Cut taxes, stop the massive spending and borrowing that is destroying our currency and our childrens birthright, reform all "entitlements" (God, I hate that word. Nobody DESERVES anything. God has blessed us with existence. Nothing can be deserved.) and start having as many people in this country pulling their own weight. There are WAY too many people living on government spending of one form or another. We may have hit a critical mass of people with their hands out this election cycle.

 

brian

Jan 6, 2009

Matthew - Rosa DeLauro is NOT a wonderful woman. She is excrement with feet. And if Pelosi goes through with her plans, the House Republicans can take off for Tahiti for the next two years for all the good showing up for work will do them. Finally, Obama's "tax cuts" are nothing of the sort. They are simply a shifting of the burden to higher income groups. So we are going to give a "tax cut" to people who don't pay taxes already, and raise the taxes on people who already pay too much. We have a word for that, and it isn't "cut", it's "welfare". If Congress had any intellectual firepower at all, they'd call in the money they have already given out in the bank bailout, tell the Detroit automakers to go to hades, and tell California to go jump in the ocean. NO MORE BAILOUTS FOR MORONS!

 

amr

Jan 6, 2009

The problem is that whatever we/congress does, the same people control congress that got us into to this mess. And the American people added to the mess in this past election. No lessons learned here.

 


Post a comment


Email:
(This will not be displayed or shared. Privacy Policy)

Display Name:

Comment:




Sports

President of the Italian Tennis Federation Francesco Ricci Bitti and U.S. Fed Cup player Melanie Oudin meet the media  ahead of the Fed Cup tennis final between Italy and the United States, in Reggio ...

ITF president says hefty fine — not ban — likely for Serena Williams over US Open tirade

Top-ranked Serena Williams will most likely receive a "significant" fine but no suspension for her U.S. Open tirade, the president of the International Tennis Federation said. Full story

Politics

Demonstrators chant on Capitol Hill in Washington, Thursday, Nov. 5, 2009, during a Republican health Care reform rally. (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana)

House Democrats clear impasse over abortion holding up vote on health care legislation

Capping months of months of struggle, House Democrats cleared an abortion-related impasse blocking a vote on sweeping health care legislation late Friday and officials expressed optimism they had finally lined up the support needed to pass President Barack Obama's top domestic priority. Full story

Entertainment

'Golden Girls' star McClanahan has bypass surgery

Rue McClanahan, who played sexy Southern belle Blanche Devereaux on "The Golden Girls," was recovering Thursday from heart bypass surgery at a New York City hospital. Full story