Opinion

[Print]  [Email]        

CBO: Republican health plan would reduce premiums, cut deficit

By: Susan Ferrechio
Chief Congressional Correspondent
11/05/09 6:30 AM EST

The Congressional Budget Office Wednesday night released its cost analysis of the Republican health care plan and found that it would reduce health care premiums and cut the deficit by $68 billion over ten years.

The Republican plan does not call for a government insurance plan but rather attempts to reform the system by creating high-risk insurance pools, allowing people to purchase health insurance policies across state lines and instituting medical malpractice reforms.

"Not only does the GOP plan lower health care costs, but it also increases access to quality care, including for those with pre-existing conditions, at a price our country can afford," House Minority Leader John Boehner, R-Ohio, said.

According to CBO, the GOP bill would indeed lower costs, particularly for small businesses that have trouble finding affordable health care policies for their employees. The report found rates would drop by seven to 10 percent for this group, and by five to eight percent for the individual market, where it can also be difficult to find affordable policies.

The GOP plan would have the smallest economic impact on the large group market that serves people working for large businesses that have access to the cheapest coverage. Those premiums would decline by zero to 3 percent, the CBO said.

The analysis shows the Republican plan would do little to expand coverage, which Democrats were quick to point out in a late night missive to reporters.

"Here's the Bottom line - Americans lose and Insurance companies win under the Republican plan," Pelosi spokesman Nadeam Elshami said.

The CBO found that under the Republican plan, insurance coverage would increase by about 3 million and that the percentage of insured non-elderly adults would remain at about 83 percent after ten years. The House bill would increase coverage to an additional 36 million people, raising the number of insured to 96 percent.

The CBO put the price tag for the GOP plan at $61 billion, a fraction of the $1.05 trillion cost estimate it gave to the House bill that lawmakers are set to vote on this weekend. And the CBO found that the Republican provision to reform medical malpractice liability would result in $41 billion in savings and increase revenues by $13 billion by reducing the cost of private health insurance plans.

 




beltway confidential

In response to the attention we gave him for his old column on how Washington has "anemic winters" because of global warming, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. tells NRO's Robert...

By a vote of 52 to 33, the Obama administration nominee to the National Labor Relations Board, Craig Becker, just failed to get the 60 votes needed for his nomination to proceed...

The highest form of flattery! Robert, declare yourself! (ap photo) Beltway Confidential knows a crush when she sees one. How else to explain the relentless mocking and...

You're beautiful, Chuck Todd. I mean that. (ap photo) On a day when many White House reporters (ahem) stayed away from the White House for snow or early-deadline...






To view this site, you need to have Flash Player 8.0 or later installed. Click here to get the latest Flash player.


Most Popular Headlines





 


 



 

Reader Comments

All comments on this page are subject to our Terms of Use and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Examiner or its staff. Comment box is limited to 250 words.

brwils

Nov 5, 2009

Pelosi can go to He**. Americans don't lose under the GOP plan. At least 86% win and millions more win when they can choose to go without insurance without the fear of being criminalized by BO/Pelosi/Reid and the other tyrants. The Revolution is coming.

 

Jeff

Nov 5, 2009

This sounds great but it's too little too late from the Republicans. This plan will get little to no coverage by the mainstream media and has already been rejected out of hand by Nancy Pelosi.

 

depaz

Nov 5, 2009

Expect those CBO employees who came up with these numbers to be pushing the unemployment rate to 10%. Such heresy!!

Jeff - I don't think it's "too little, too late". I think it's been there for a long time, but has continued to get dismissed by the queen.

 

Mad Monica

Nov 5, 2009

Wait... I thought the republicans weren't offering any ideas... oh yeah.. just like the DNC came out the winners Tuesday night. Riiiiiight. Don't be surprised, however, if the Obama/Pelosi/Reid brigade doesn't ever acknowledge this exists.

 

bobc

Nov 5, 2009

Pelosi won't allow this to see the light of day!

Listen, Politicians...not one red cent should go to illegal aliens & if you grant amnesty, they will bring in their entire families...Americans are NOT responsible for them!

You can cut out all perks to them and we would save a lot of money!

Let LaRaza, MALDEF, LULAC, etc. to use that tax payers $$$ they get, to give illegals health care!

 

joyce

Nov 5, 2009

PLEASE, Republicans, don't offer other legislation to counter the Dems reform bill. Kill the health care reform bill and write a tort reform bill and allow us to purchase health insurance across state lines, repair Medicare and Medicaid by going after the fraud and jail the guilty people! But for God's sake, don't add to the bankrupt nation by attempting to pass health care reform.

 

lynne

Nov 5, 2009

Where is the transparent government that was promised? It;s a one sided government "DEMOCRATS ONLY" This is the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA a free society not a socialist country at least not yet. We need health care reform but not this joke of a bill. Thankfully we do have elections coming up next year.

 

laslavic

Nov 5, 2009

how difficult will it be to fix the mess the dems are creating once we kick them all out of office? The voters they are paying off wouldn't vote for anything other than a democrat so why care what they think. Get rid of the bums in 2010 and emasculate the white house as the dems did when Bush was in the house and reverse the damaging policy. It's couldn't be any worse than what the leftist cabal has in store for us.

 

mark c

Nov 5, 2009

like all abusers, the Republican party is rediscovering the virtues that led to the marriage only after being confronted with a stack of packed bags by the door. these are great ideas today and were great ideas 8 years ago. What took you so long?

 

Nov 5, 2009

One of these cases where less equals more. Go Republicans!
Bob

 

bob

Nov 5, 2009

Join the campaign to say NO to socialized medicine!

Send a personalized note to your members of Congress (or ALL members) and tell them to vote NO on Obamacare – before it’s too late!

http://conservativeoutpost.com/campaign/cta/tell_congress_no_socialized_medicine

 

jimmy

Nov 5, 2009

What I want to know is how the GOP plan intends to account for the still uninsured who will go to emergency rooms where taxpayers will still have to pick up the tab. A health insurance plan that doesn't address paying for the healthcare of the uninsured beyond what we have now is simply not tolerable. Until the GOP addresses this problem, their proposal must be taken for the joke that it is.

 

petep

Nov 5, 2009

jimmy, we're going to pay for them, no matter what.

 

OK

Nov 5, 2009

Susie, talk about Burying the Lede - and the story.

Try paragraph eight of Susie's nine-paragraph tale:

"The CBO found that under the Republican plan, insurance coverage would increase by about 3 million and that the percentage of insured non-elderly adults would remain at about 83 percent after ten years. The House bill would increase coverage to an additional 36 million people, raising the number of insured to 96 percent."

Democratic bill would cover 36 million who lack coverage.

Conservative bill would cover 3 million.

That's a 12:1 ratio, kids.

Democratic bill would cover 96 percent of all Americans.

Conservative bill would cover about 83 percent.

Umm, 96 is more than 83. Even Ayn Rand and Milton Friedman knew that.

Susie, why'd you bury the lede? On orders from the Indy's Conservative bosses? Or did you think that one up all by yourself?

 

Scotty

Nov 5, 2009

@OK, guess you didn't see the CBO stats that claim only about 6 million will be covered by the "public-option" in 2019? What happened to the 47 million uninsured claims by Obama, Pelosi, Reid? What about the 30 million uninsured claim? The Donkeys keep changing numbers and are using fraudulent accounting.

Then again, I'm sure you believe the government run health care scam will cost us nothing and will not add to the deficit? You probably believe the government will save us money by cutting fraud and waste?

Tell us how great the government has been with cutting fraud and waste from the bankrupt systems of Medicare/Medicaid and Social Security.

Keep drinking theh kool-aid and being a follower who spews MSNBC & DNC talking points. I'll wait for a liberal comeback but make sure you bring the facts and not notes from wikipedia.

 

cking

Nov 5, 2009

Hey OK

the Republican plan is not trying to guarantee coverage to the alleged 36million.

those numbers include illegals, people who dont buy coverage and people who already qualify for medicaid. the key is reducing premiums.

allow people to buy the coverage they want not loaded up with a bunch of stuff people dont want

 

Ken

Nov 5, 2009

OK.....when you factor out illegal aliens, the young that can afford health insurance, but opt for a new truck and those that qualify for free health care, but are too lazy to sign up, we are only taking about 4% of the country. I am against turning our heath care into socialized medicine because it doesn't cover 4% of the dead-beats in this country. You liberals are always penalizing the responsible while rewarding the irresponsible. I don't want the government to take care of me and I'm sick of you liberals taxing me to death in order for democrats to take care of their ever entitled supporters.

 

LP

Nov 5, 2009

Oh Boy!!!!! 3 million more insured!!! Why, that solves everything doesn't it? Of COURSE it costs less... it does almost NOTHING!! Too funny.

 

Anonymous

Nov 5, 2009

I just do not understand...a proposal for government to take over a private sector of the economy! Capitalism has been working well in this country for the past 233 years. Why change something that has worked so well? It isn't capitalism that has failed people, it is people that burden the system with socialist reforms. This is an excellent way to make one of the best devises in the world fail! Remember "that government is best which governs least"- Thomas Jefferson

 

milo janus

Nov 5, 2009

No wonder the public trust Dems more the Repubs on health care, even at this stage in the game. 3 million people... whoah, boys! That doesn't even keep up with population growth. Just sit this one out, fellas.

Oh, and the Dem plan doesn't have the government take over the private sector. Do 5 seconds of homework.

 

gobnait

Nov 6, 2009

Someone posted ...'too little, too late from the Reps...'. The Republicans have been pressing for their points for months and the Democrats have refused to consider them time and time again-proof positive that they don't care about the uninsured; they're only interested in grabbing power and control!!!

 

ines

Nov 6, 2009

So the republicians answer to health care is to deny patients the right to sue their doctor. So when some doctor cuts off the wrong leg, the money you would have gotten if you sued will pay for those millions of people left out of the republician plan. Now don't you feel better?

 

Ken

Nov 6, 2009

The only real difference between socialism and communism is ownership of businesses. Consequently, you liberals are closer to being communists than you know. You go from your mother's teat to suckling the government. Why don't you try personal responsibility for a change? The first colony in America tried to get through the first winter using a socialistic approach and it nearly wiped out the whole colony. The next winter they used a conservative (personal responsibility) approach and all was well. Your social programs are going to be the downfall of this country. I prefer the USA in lieu of the democrats version of the USSA.

 

Chaarlotte Poirier

Nov 7, 2009

TO WHOM THIS MAY CONCERN OR PASS THE BUCK WHY HASN'T THE AMERICAN GOV. PAY BACK ALL THE MONIES HARD WORKING PEOPLE
HAVE PAYED INTO IT ONLY GET A FACTION
OF WHAT THEY SHOULD BE INTITLED TOO.?
WHY ARE GRANTS PAYED TO INDIAN ORGANIZATIONS AND MOORE GRANTS PAYED FROM TAXES THAT THEY CALL FREE MONEY !
MY HASBAND HAS A NINE FIGURE THAT PAYED INTO SOCIAL SECURITY SINCE 1945 TILL NOW
AND WANT IF HE WANTED ALL HIS MONEY BACK BECUASE HE DOESNT WANT TO SUPPORT THE SCRAMES AND OVER BILLING OR JUST WAITING FOR HIM TO DIE SO THE GOV. CAN REAP THE REST OF HIS HARD EARNED MONEY
OR TRY TO BARROW MONEY TO PAY OFF BILLS HE WAS NOT COVERED AT THE TIME .........
I BET YOU DON"T HAVE THE BALLS TO ANSWER
THIS .............AND WE ARE FOR SOCIALIZIED MEDICINE..

 

Nov 7, 2009

Another Grand Act of the democrats. Spare me and the rest of us, please!

 

Nov 7, 2009

A young, vibrant government who is quite willing to kill unwanted babies and their unwanted elders. God help us!

 

Robert Su, M.D.

Nov 7, 2009

Use Autonomous Care that includes a non-profit regional self-insurance pool for catastrophic coverage and Health Savings Accounts for deductibles. The self-insurance pools can also help shop for other insurance plans for individual's need. Visit www.autonomouscare.info.

 

ME

Nov 8, 2009

All I will say is...my uncle is a doctor. He says we will quit his practice the day government takes over healthcare. Why? Because government starts dictating to doctors how to treat their patients. That's one reason doctors are starting to not accept medicare. (Besides the fact Medicare barely pays anything at all) Politicians who have NEVER BEEN TRAINED IN MEDICINE try to tell doctors what treatments to give. I've heard the similar from other doctors--the estimate is 45% will quit if Obamacare comes to pass. How will 45% of doctors quitting the trade effect our economy? Healthcare costs will skyrocket because of supply and demand, and things will be rationed. Exact opposite of what a healthcare reform plan is supposed to do.

 

bobb

Nov 8, 2009

The GOP had the president for 8 years and the congress for six and they could have put their fixes to health care into law if they wanted to.

Many people posting don't seem to know that the democratic bill relies mostly on private insurance companies, and not on the government owning the insurance industry.

Some brave republicans have advocated doing away with our existing socialized medicine, Medicare, but you won't hear anyone in congress or who wants to be in congress saying it. If you want to do away with socialize medicine start with Medicare.

 

Bowen747

Nov 9, 2009

Yea' Obama is one step closer to seeing his plan of the American overhaul of the health care system being fulfilled. All you right wing LOONS keep crying, whinning, snibbling (like a baby ) and complaining and there is not one DAMM thing you or your republicans in D.C. can do to stop it. Call it socialism or communism or whatever, you're just mad as hell that this black president is having it his way and you all are powerless to stop him. Hell i'll bet you sidewinders even lose sleep at night over this. Obama has gotten his stimilus bill through, placed a Latina on the high court, now moving healthcare into a passable position and next give citizenship to all the illegals in the U.S. get rid of the don't ask don't tell policy in the military, my my my he's just having it all his way and you can't stop him. America has changed and you will never "Have my America back" because those days are long gone. So suck it up and deal with it LOSERSSSSSSSSSSS''''''' Ha Ha I just love it.

 

Cal

Nov 10, 2009

What a blatantly dishonest article. Contrary to Boehner's claim, the GOP bill does NOTHING to end discrimination against pre-existing conditions, and while it does reduce the deficit, the Democrats' bill reduces it by billions more. Also the number of uninsured would actually be higher than it is now under the Republican bill. The three million additional people getting insured barely even keeps pace with population growth. This was a bill literally written by the insurance lobby, and it's in no way real reform.

 

Bobby The Independent

Nov 24, 2009

Every civilized country in the world has a universal health plan except for what we know as the greatest and most powerful country in the world, the USA. Our government(namely Republicans)are sold out to the insurance lobbyist and are about protecting their best interest in this hideous thing called capitalism. What ever happened to "WE THE PEOPLE?" I mean any type of health plan in this county has been long needed. People work all their lives and pay into FICA and Medicare and still cannot survive. It's not the USA but the people who has run the USA who are about greed and capitalism over moral values and health concerns.

Adversary people shut the hell up and allow Obama to work his plan. Republicans had their chance and screwed this up royally, to the point that the nation of right wingers elected the worst unqualified president in history. And now you people are still up to your old antics and brainwashing tactics (to the weak Americans). GIVE IT UP, why don't you..?

 

hg

Nov 28, 2009

ya for sure

 

F U

Nov 28, 2009

bowen747, first of all your a complete idiot...how can you even call yourself an American. I cant believe the words that come out of your mouth...hope u rot in hell....

 

iscount Christian Louboutin Sandals

Dec 5, 2009

replica watches
Panerai watch for sale
Rolex Explorer watches
replica Breitling
Rolex Sea-Dweller replica
tiffany sale

 

laptop battery onsale

Dec 21, 2009

laptop battery onsale laptop battery onsale laptop battery onsale

 

ugg mm

Dec 22, 2009

UGG クラシックトール
UGG Classic Short
UGG クラシックショート
UGG Classic Cardy
UGGクラシックキャディ
UGG ニットブーツ

 

Albert P

Dec 23, 2009

they have taken away so much of the original health plan from the beginning to now that it just don't make sense to even vote on itI thought we were going to get a plan like the senators have.

 

asder

Jan 2, 2010

Thanks for your useful info, I think it's a good topic
çizgi film
kayu çizgi filmini izle
çizgi film izle
caillou izle
gece bahçesi izle

 

aaren

Jan 5, 2010

they have taken away so much of the original health plan from the beginning to now that it just don't make sense to even vote on itI thought we were going to get a plan like the senators have.
Custom Essay | Thesis | Buy Assignment | Coursework Help

 

Jan 11, 2010

projeksiyon

 

Joe H

Jan 24, 2010

To all those that look at 3 mil extra being covered...
Health care reform is important for multiple reasons, but the only one that started the reform debate is COST. There would be no debate about all of the unisured if our health care was sustainable. Don't get me wrong, I'm a caring human being & would like to see us do what we can for our neighbors. But first things first, reduce the costs and then worry about feeding a fish for a day. And the Republican plan is good because it actually addresses the true problem.

 

Joe H

Jan 24, 2010

Bobby, ever universal health care system in the world is either unstainable (France, Korea, Japan...) & putting contries into debt or has very inadequate care (England -- not sure about the finances).

 

mytiffany

Jan 25, 2010

And a substantial component tiffanys of that burden is because of tiffany co the high levels of child mortality in Africa tiffany rings compared to other regions tiffany jewellery.

 

adult

Jan 27, 2010

dwewdwd

 


Post a comment


Email:
(This will not be displayed or shared. Privacy Policy)

Your Name:

Comment:




Local

Another snowball fight planned for Dupont Circle

The Official Dupont Circle Snowball Fight facebook fanpage has over 6,000 fans now, and it looks as if snowed in DC'ers will return for another battle. Full story

Politics

GOP winning war over Miranda rights for terrorists

Even as the administration defends its decision to grant accused Detroit bomber Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab the right to remain silent, the president himself is hinting that things might be done differently in the future. Full story

Local

D.C. region braces for up to 20 more inches of snow

The National Weather Service has the entire D.C. metro area, from Prince William County north, under a winter storm warning for 10 to 20 inches of snow. Forecasters have had their eyes on this storm for days, but the projected snow totals were bumped up late Monday. Full story