Opinion

[Print]  [Email]        

CEI releases global warming study censored by Obama's EPA

By: Kevin Mooney
Commentary Staff Writer
06/26/09 12:09 PM EDT

Natural forces as opposed to human activity are largely responsible for temperature fluctuations, according to a new study the Competitive Enterprise Institute (CEI) released today as Congress prepares to vote on global warming legislation.

Internal email messages show the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) suppressed the report and silenced the author because the scientific evidence did not square with the Obama administration’s agenda of regulating carbon dioxide, CEI claims. The EPA has become overly reliant upon outdated information from the United Nations and has ignored major new scientific developments, the censored study concludes.
“While we hoped that the EPA would release the final report, we’re tired of waiting for this agency to become transparent, even though its administrator has been talking transparency, since she took office,” said CEI General Counsel Sam Kazman.
New scientific data highlighted in the report shows that ocean cycles and solar cycles are probably the most important factors behind temperature fluctuations. Moreover, satellite information now indicates there is little chance of endangerment from greenhouse gases, according to the report.
Some of the major developments overlooked by EPA official include a continued decline in global temperatures, an emerging consensus that hurricanes will not be more frequent or intense and new studies that demonstrate water vapor will have a moderating influence on temperature.
Going forward, CEI has called upon the EPA to independently analyze the science and to become more transparent in its own reporting.



beltway confidential

Upstart Texas gubernatorial candidate Debra Medina is gaining in the polls and now sits 4 points behind Kay Bailey Hutchison. From PPP: Medina is coming on strong and polls...

A cursory reading of this Las Vegas Sun report, "Prospects For Organized Labor's Legislative Agenda Rapidly Fading," suggests -- and not without evidence -- that Big Labor isn't...

The headline on Bloomberg's obituary for the recently deceased Rep. John Murtha, D-Pa., is "Lawmaker Murtha, Supporter of Troops, Dies at Age 77." That's a bizarre headline for...

Republicans and business interests were already deeply suspect of Craig Becker, Obama's nominee to the National Labor Relations Board. Becker was formerly counsel to the AFL-CIO...






To view this site, you need to have Flash Player 8.0 or later installed. Click here to get the latest Flash player.


Most Popular Headlines





 


 



 

Reader Comments

All comments on this page are subject to our Terms of Use and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Examiner or its staff. Comment box is limited to 250 words.

bbb

Jun 26, 2009

I would LOVE to see one member of Congress who votes for this bill (a.k.a. Democrats) actually have the knowledge to draw a carbon dioxide molecule, or an ozone ion, or well, ANYTHING actually on a 7th grade level science (9th grade if one is in remedial science). Don't think Gore could do it, but that's not required of Hollywood, or the Nobel Prize, to actually know and understand something.

 

Mike Smith

Jun 26, 2009

Kevin Mooney, are you aware of the background of CEI (its funders and its aims?). Either you don't, in which case you should research your sources more, or you do in which case you should have not put their spin on your article. Either way, you clearly aren't capable of journalism, as either error is inexcusable.

 

Richard H.

Jun 26, 2009

I've read the paper/draft released by the CEI. It's interesting that it was censored because it's written in a way that seems to be in the best interest of the EPA. Sure it questions the belief that all global warming is man made, and questions our full understanding of the principals involved. But it's also written in a way to say "Hey! we need to cover our tails on this." Items like "We need to understand XXX better because if we don't and it proves to be wrong the EPA will take the blame not the IPCC"

 

Hank

Jun 26, 2009

Mike Smith, Yours is the same old lame talking point that clouds any furthering of the science or discussion on anthropogenic global warming - the skeptics are in the tank with big oil and the proponents are in the tank with liberal politicians. Journalism is about bringing the story to the public, not about being a scientist trained in all fields nor checking out every reference in the report (which are mostly valid sources by the way). The reality is there is new "peer reviewed" science that is gaining attention that contradicts some of the underpinnings of the AGW hypothesis. At a time when the science is the deciding factor in tremendously expensive political decisions, it only makes sense to me that the newer science needs to be considered. That's all Mooney is saying. To say that the new science has arrived too late to make its contribution to our understanding of global warming is foolish in this context.

 

Pitt

Jun 26, 2009

AH.....thankfully Lord Obama, the most merciful, has seen fit to re-introduce "science" into policy making. /sarcasm off/ Apparently, it's OK to exclude any science that is in contradiction to liberal orthodoxy.

 

Pitt

Jun 26, 2009

AH.....thankfully Lord Obama, the most merciful, has seen fit to re-introduce "science" into policy making. /sarcasm off/ Apparently, it's OK to exclude any science that is in contradiction to liberal orthodoxy.

 

Stacy

Jun 26, 2009

Mike Smith, refute the data, if you can. You attack CEI which is bringing attention to the fact that an EPA administrator attempted to suppress scientific data because it would "damage" the Obama administration policy on climate change. In other words, yet again Obama says one thing and does another - science is taking a back seat to ideology, even though he said the Obama Era would be science above ideology. Obama loves himself and his party more than his country or its principles. November 2010 cannot come soon enough - time to make Obama a lame duck. Transparency. Ha!

 

Alfred J. Lemire

Jun 27, 2009

I took journalism courses at Maryland in College Park and worked nearly seven years as a newspaper reporter. Mr. Smith errs. Mr. Mooney reported the facts & did not put "their [CEI's] spin" on his article. One can dispute the findings and the claim of an "emerging consensus" re: hurricanes, but Mr. Mooney reported that which he has observed. Mr. Smith wanted Mr. Mooney to reference and presumably catgorize the CEI's funders and aims, displacing relevant facts in the 235-word article. The facts and the science referenced in the suppressed EPA report matter to an analysis of climate patterns and public policy decisions, not who supports the work of the CEI.

 

Alfred J. Lemire

Jun 27, 2009

And "catgorize" should have been "categorize." I do make typos from time to time. I wrote and edited too quickly. And Mr. Smith's criticism brings to mind a David Espo AP report last September in Colorado on a Sarah Palin speech. His fourth paragraph started with, "[i]n fact, independent groups such as the Tax Policy Center" and went on to cite one of its findings that four out of five U.S. households would get tax cuts through an Obama proposal. The Tax Policy Center is affiliated with the Brookings Institution. Independent? Well, perhaps of direct government control, but it has a point of view. And funders. And I'm waiting for my tax cut. Mr. Smith should take a closer look at what the AP does in its reports. Mr. Espo did what he could to refute Gov. Palin’s claims in a report on her speech, something I never saw in AP reports on Obama. Mr. Espo is capable of journalism; so is Mr. Mooney.

 

Peter Williams

Jun 28, 2009

This is a fascinating time in which we live as we watch the great liberal experiments of our time pile great damage on top of the damage caused by the great liberal experiments of the past. Belief in idealized outcomes outweighs rational thought. This is how civilizations destroy themselves.

 

WeWon

Jun 28, 2009

Hey, We won. This means James Hansen can be arrested and stay on as a valued member of our team. It also means that heretics like these renegade EPA employees can be disciplined, be fired and banned from working in this important field. The planet and our Presidents reputation is too important to risk on anything less than draconian tactics. If a few people have to be sacrificed for our needs than so be it. WE WON!

 

WeWon

Jun 28, 2009

Hey, We won. This means James Hansen can be arrested and stay on as a valued member of our team. It also means that heretics like these renegade EPA employees can be disciplined, be fired and banned from working in this important field. The planet and our Presidents reputation is too important to risk on anything less than draconian tactics. If a few people have to be sacrificed for our needs than so be it. WE WON!

 

Mike Smith

Jun 28, 2009

(my last comment! maybe :P) Lemire said "Mr. Smith wanted Mr. Mooney to reference and presumably catgorize the CEI's funders and aims," no I didn't, although it might have been a good idea. It would have been better still to interview others around the story (e.g. climate scientists?) who would be able to say if the report is an important scoop, or a load of rubbish.

 

Mike Smith

Jun 28, 2009

To the newspaper: Did you have to censor my 2 other comments? I was replying to the other posters, and trying to explain the problems with the report.

 

Paul Lindsey

Jun 28, 2009

Could the CEI's actions bringing this quashed report and the associated emails to light be the reason that Nancy Pelosi and the House Democratic leadership were so insistent on getting a vote on ACES on Friday?

 

Mike Smith

Jun 29, 2009

Stacy said, "Mike Smith, refute the data, if you can." I posted an extended comment twice, explaining the problems with the data. Both times it didn't make it onto this comments section. I'd ask that you go read www.realclimate.org where climate scientists are explaining the problems with the report. Thanks, Mike.

 

Sandy

Jun 29, 2009

Hopefully someone out there can answer this question. What human activity caused the oceans in the Southwestern part of the US (LV NV area is a good example) to become desert and the glaciers in the upper part of N. America to melt?

 

WW2 Vet

Jun 29, 2009

lets see how many of the liberal newsmedia will publish the findings of the CEI, Foxx news is one of the very few however that will keep you abrest of all the news. That is why Obama and his hebchmen are trying to run Fox off the air. Keep up your good newcasting Fox.

 

Michael

Jul 2, 2009

This story has been debunked as completely bogus. Amazing that nobody here has posted the conflict of interest between the CEI (supported by multiple energy interests) and the story itself. Hey, you flat-earth folks: there are over 1000 peer reviewed studies that support human-induced global warming. There are 0 peer reviewed studies that refute it. Get a life people.

 

Hey Michael

Jul 6, 2009

There is not a lot of money in non-human warming, is there? Debunked? Where and by whom?

 

Common Sense

Nov 29, 2009

Can you tree huggers say, "Hacked eco-nut email"? Congrats liberal loons...you've politicized the only remaining un-biased discipline in the world- science.

 

iscount Christian Louboutin Sandals

Dec 5, 2009

replica watches
Concord watches
Louis Vuitton watch for sale
Rolex Masterpiece replica
Lady Watch for sale
bar for you

 

ugg sale

Dec 21, 2009

ugg sale ugg sale ugg sale

 

Nike mm

Dec 25, 2009

ggggxcgAir Max 360
kobe bryant shoes
Nike Kobe 4
Nike Kobe 5
Air Max 90
Air Max 1
North Face Jacket
North Face

 

Nike mm

Dec 25, 2009

Nike Kobe IV
Lebron James Shoes
Lebron James Shoes
nike basketball shoes
air max 2009
nike air max 2009
The North Face
Discount North Face

 

jack wills mm

Dec 25, 2009

jackwills
billy jack wills
jack wills
buy jack wills
jack wills Apparel
Jack Wills Fashion Clothing
Cheap North Face Jacket
Cheap North Face

 

kissnfl mm

Dec 25, 2009

authentic football jerseys
authentic jerseys
authentic nfl jerseys
authentic nhl jerseys
buy nfl jerseys

ugg mm

Dec 25, 2009

UGG クラシックトール
UGG Classic Short
UGG クラシックショート
UGG Classic Cardy
UGGクラシックキャディ
UGG ニットブーツ

 

ugg mm

Dec 25, 2009

UGG クラシックトール
UGG Classic Short
UGG クラシックショート
UGG Classic Cardy
UGGクラシックキャディ
UGG ニットブーツ

 

ugg mm

Dec 25, 2009

UGG クラシックトール
UGG Classic Short

 

nike yy

Jan 3, 2010

Nike Air Max
Nike Shox Shoes
Nike Dunk SB
Air Jordans
Nike Air Shoes
Nike max shoes

 

nike yy

Jan 3, 2010

Nike Air Max
Nike Shox Shoes
Nike Dunk SB
Air Jordans
Nike Air Shoes
Nike max shoes

 

nike yy

Jan 3, 2010

Nike Air Max
Nike Shox Shoes
Nike Dunk SB
Air Jordans
Nike Air Shoes
Nike max shoes

 

nike yy

Jan 3, 2010

Nike Air Max
Nike Shox Shoes
Nike Dunk SB
Air Jordans
Nike Air Shoes
Nike max shoes

 

Timberland for kids

Jan 4, 2010

Timberland for kids
Mens timberland boots
Womens timberland boots
Cheap timberland boots
Timberland winter boots

 

Timberland uk

Jan 4, 2010

Timberland shoes
Timberland uk
Timberland chukka
Timberland kids
Mens roll top Boots

 

Womens Roll-Top Boots

Jan 4, 2010

[Womens Roll-Top Boots
Womens High Top Boots
Womens 6 Inch Boots
Mens Custom Boots
Mens Chukka Boots

 

Timeberland boots sale

Jan 4, 2010

Custom timberland boots
Wholesale timberland boots
Cheap timberland shoes
Timeberland boots sale
Discount timberland boots

 

Timberland outdoor

Jan 4, 2010

Timberland work boots
Timberland outdoor
Timberland Womens Shoes

 

UGG Classic Cardy

Jan 4, 2010

UGG ウルトラトール
UGG ウルトラショート
UGG Classic Croche
UGGニットブーツ
UGG クラシッククロシェ

 

UGG クラシックショート

Jan 4, 2010

UGG クラシックショート
ugg ショート ブーツ
UGG Classic Cardy
UGGクラシックキャディ
UGG ニットブーツ
UGG クラシックブーツ

 

UGG クラシックブーツ

Jan 4, 2010

UGG クラシックブーツ
UGG AUSTRALLIA
UGG オーストラリア
UGG ムートンブーツ
UGG ブーツ

 

UGG シープスキンブーツ

Jan 4, 2010

UGG シープスキンブーツ
UGG Suede Boots
UGG スウェード ブーツ
uggブーツ クラシック
ムートンブーツ ugg

 

UGG Classic Cardy

Jan 4, 2010

UGG ウルトラトール
UGG ウルトラショート
UGG Classic Croche
UGGニットブーツ
UGG クラシッククロシェ

 

Timberland for kids

Jan 4, 2010

Timberland for kids
Mens timberland boots
Womens timberland boots
Cheap timberland boots
Timberland winter boots

 

Timberland for kids

Jan 4, 2010

Timberland for kids
Mens timberland boots
Womens timberland boots
Cheap timberland boots
Timberland winter boots

 

Timberland work boots

Jan 4, 2010

Timberland work boots
Timberland waterproof
Timberland store
Waterproof boots
Timberland pro

 

Timberland uk

Jan 4, 2010

Timberland shoes
Timberland uk
Timberland chukka
Timberland kids
Mens roll top Boots

 

Womens Roll-Top Boots

Jan 4, 2010

[Womens Roll-Top Boots
Womens High Top Boots
Womens 6 Inch Boots
Mens Custom Boots
Mens Chukka Boots

 

Timeberland boots sale

Jan 4, 2010

Custom timberland boots
Wholesale timberland boots
Cheap timberland shoes
Timeberland boots sale
Discount timberland boots

 

Timberland outdoor

Jan 4, 2010

Timberland work boots
Timberland outdoor
Timberland Womens Shoes

 

UGG Classic Cardy

Jan 4, 2010

UGG ウルトラトール
UGG ウルトラショート
UGG Classic Croche
UGGニットブーツ
UGG クラシッククロシェ

 

UGG クラシックショート

Jan 4, 2010

UGG クラシックショート
ugg ショート ブーツ
UGG Classic Cardy
UGGクラシックキャディ
UGG ニットブーツ
UGG クラシックブーツ

 

UGG クラシックブーツ

Jan 4, 2010

UGG クラシックブーツ
UGG AUSTRALLIA
UGG オーストラリア
UGG ムートンブーツ
UGG ブーツ

 

UGG シープスキンブーツ

Jan 4, 2010

UGG シープスキンブーツ
UGG Suede Boots
UGG スウェード ブーツ
uggブーツ クラシック
ムートンブーツ ugg

 

UGG Classic Cardy

Jan 4, 2010

UGG ウルトラトール
UGG ウルトラショート
UGG Classic Croche
UGGニットブーツ
UGG クラシッククロシェ

 

Timberland for kids

Jan 4, 2010

Timberland for kids
Mens timberland boots
Womens timberland boots
Cheap timberland boots
Timberland winter boots

 

Timberland work boots

Jan 4, 2010

Timberland work boots
Timberland waterproof
Timberland store
Waterproof boots
Timberland pro

 

Timberland uk

Jan 4, 2010

Timberland shoes
Timberland uk
Timberland chukka
Timberland kids
Mens roll top Boots

 

Womens Roll-Top Boots

Jan 4, 2010

[Womens Roll-Top Boots
Womens High Top Boots
Womens 6 Inch Boots
Mens Custom Boots
Mens Chukka Boots

 

Womens Roll-Top Boots

Jan 4, 2010

[Womens Roll-Top Boots
Womens High Top Boots
Womens 6 Inch Boots
Mens Custom Boots
Mens Chukka Boots

 

Timeberland boots sale

Jan 4, 2010

Custom timberland boots
Wholesale timberland boots
Cheap timberland shoes
Timeberland boots sale
Discount timberland boots

 

Timberland outdoor

Jan 4, 2010

Timberland work boots
Timberland outdoor
Timberland Womens Shoes

 

UGG Classic Cardy

Jan 4, 2010

UGG ウルトラトール
UGG ウルトラショート
UGG Classic Croche
UGGニットブーツ
UGG クラシッククロシェ

 

UGG クラシックショート

Jan 4, 2010

UGG クラシックショート
ugg ショート ブーツ
UGG Classic Cardy
UGGクラシックキャディ
UGG ニットブーツ
UGG クラシックブーツ

 

UGG クラシックブーツ

Jan 4, 2010

UGG クラシックブーツ
UGG AUSTRALLIA
UGG オーストラリア
UGG ムートンブーツ
UGG ブーツ

 

UGG シープスキンブーツ

Jan 4, 2010

UGG シープスキンブーツ
UGG Suede Boots
UGG スウェード ブーツ
uggブーツ クラシック
ムートンブーツ ugg

 

UGG Classic Cardy

Jan 4, 2010

UGG ウルトラトール
UGG ウルトラショート
UGG Classic Croche
UGGニットブーツ
UGG クラシッククロシェ

 

lingerie

Jan 7, 2010

Sexy Lingerie
Valentine Lingerie
fancy dress
adult costumes
party costumes
Wholesale Lingerie

 


Post a comment


Email:
(This will not be displayed or shared. Privacy Policy)

Your Name:

Comment:




Local

Another snowball fight planned for Dupont Circle

The Official Dupont Circle Snowball Fight facebook fanpage has over 6,000 fans now, and it looks as if snowed in DC'ers will return for another battle. Full story

Politics

GOP winning war over Miranda rights for terrorists

Even as the administration defends its decision to grant accused Detroit bomber Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab the right to remain silent, the president himself is hinting that things might be done differently in the future. Full story

Local

D.C. region braces for up to 20 more inches of snow

The National Weather Service has the entire D.C. metro area, from Prince William County north, under a winter storm warning for 10 to 20 inches of snow. Forecasters have had their eyes on this storm for days, but the projected snow totals were bumped up late Monday. Full story