 |
Leahy explains his "wise Latina" misquote, but the video shows...
By: Byron York
Chief Political Correspondent
07/15/09 7:39 AM EDT
In his opening questioning of Sonia Sotomayor, Senate Judiciary Committee chairman Patrick Leahy substantially misquoted Sotomayor's famous "wise Latina" speech. "You said that, quote, you 'would hope that a wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would reach wise decisions…'" Leahy said to Sotomayor. "So tell us, you've heard all of these charges and countercharges, the 'wise Latina' and on and on…tell us what's going on."
Leahy's version of Sotomayor's quote was not what Sotomayor actually said. What she said, in her 2001 Berkeley speech was, "I would hope that a wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would more often than not reach a better conclusion than a white male who hasn't lived that life." [Emphasis added.]
After the hearings were over Tuesday, I asked Leahy about the misquote. "I was doing it from memory," Leahy explained. "But I knew that she would -- she stated exactly what she said, and the statement is in the record." Leahy added that he did not consider Sotomayor's precise words very important; her response, he said, was much more critical.
That's Leahy's explanation. But video of his question is available on YouTube, and it certainly appears that Leahy was reading from a text when he misquoted Sotomayor. Perhaps Leahy was forming his question while looking at some other text, but there is no doubt he was looking at papers when he posed the question to Sotomayor. You can judge for yourself here.
More from Byron York
- GOP responds: White House 'trying to pass the buck'
- White House: People who criticize us are helping al Qaeda
- GOP winning war over Miranda rights for terrorists
- GOP fires back: White House did not tell us about reading Abdulmutallab his rights
- White House: Top GOP leaders didn't object to reading Abdulmutallab his rights
Follow The Examiner
