Opinion

[Print]  [Email]        

That 1,990-page Democratic health care bill? It's longer now; includes new government controls

By: Byron York
Chief Political Correspondent
11/05/09 9:17 AM EST

It's become common practice to refer to the House Democrats' national health care bill as being 1,990 pages long. That's true of the bill introduced last week by Speaker Nancy Pelosi. But now Democrats have added a 42-page "manager's amendment" to the bill. Some of the new language in the amendment replaces material already in the bill, but there are enough new provisions to ensure that the bill is now more than 2,000 pages long. And there will likely be even more additions to the bill before the final debate.

What's more important is what is in the new amendment. Much of it reflects Democrats' concerns that their bill would cause an increase in health insurance premiums. Remember when the House leadership, the White House, and sympathetic media commentators everywhere attacked the insurance industry for predicting that the Democratic bill would cause premiums to go up? The manager's amendment is, in effect, the House Democrats' admission that it would do just that. Their answer: more government control. The new language sets up a process for the government to monitor "unjustified premium increases" and threaten insurance companies with exclusion from the government-run Health Insurance Exchange if they exhibit a "pattern of excessive or unjustified premium increases." The government, of course, will determine what is "excessive" or "unjustified."
 




beltway confidential

In response to the attention we gave him for his old column on how Washington has "anemic winters" because of global warming, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. tells NRO's Robert...

By a vote of 52 to 33, the Obama administration nominee to the National Labor Relations Board, Craig Becker, just failed to get the 60 votes needed for his nomination to proceed...

The highest form of flattery! Robert, declare yourself! (ap photo) Beltway Confidential knows a crush when she sees one. How else to explain the relentless mocking and...

You're beautiful, Chuck Todd. I mean that. (ap photo) On a day when many White House reporters (ahem) stayed away from the White House for snow or early-deadline...






To view this site, you need to have Flash Player 8.0 or later installed. Click here to get the latest Flash player.


Most Popular Headlines





 


 



 

Reader Comments

All comments on this page are subject to our Terms of Use and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Examiner or its staff. Comment box is limited to 250 words.

Mad Monica

Nov 5, 2009

I wonder if the libs will ever admit this healthcare thing isn't about helping the people. It's about gaining more power. If this was about actually helping the people, they'd be looking at tort reform and other actual efforts to lower costs. Nope. This is all about yet another power grab.

 

bobc

Nov 5, 2009

I have lost all respect for our government officials, they lie so much, they don't know the truth!

 

flacracker

Nov 5, 2009

The problem is how in heck do you get Congress to listen to common sense. I write my senator and my representative and I get back "F-Key" responses, and "I value your opinion." Baloney! They don't believe it and neither do I. Time to pull the plug on the swamp and drain it into the sewer. Come on 2010 and 2012.

 

markit8dude

Nov 5, 2009

I'm 'starting' to 'think' Obama's top domestic priority S/B JOBS. You know, to pay for this 'well thought through' forced health insurance plan..
The highest uninsured demographic: 18-29 year olds, not senior citizens.
The highest unemployed demographic: recent college grads.. how will they pay for 'strongarm' health insurance if unemployed?

 

LarryD

Nov 5, 2009

So instead of increasing premiums, private insurance will just become unavailable.

That's what happens when price controls cap prices below cost levels. It's already happening with Medicare, many doctors simply won't accept any new patients who are on Medicare, because Medicare doesn't cover costs.

 

iconoclast

Nov 5, 2009

Price controls combined with benefit mandates = rationing and reduction in quality.

This equation has been known (and reproven) for decades. Only a population that has been propagandized for years would be ignorant of that simple truth.

 

Some Guy

Nov 5, 2009

Of course, every cost increase will be unjustified, if you didn't unionize your company.

Pelosi and Reid WILL pass this bill. They don't care if every moderate Dem gets thrown out, next year, because they are looking at the long term implication of getting 25% of the economy under the control of unions that will reliably vote Dem forever.

 

Guy Jones

Nov 5, 2009

The bill is insanity incarnate. I started delving into it yesterday. So far, I notice the bill contains a provision mandating what percentage of every dollar received by insurance companies is spent on care. Honestly, as long as an insurer is financially solvent and pays honest claims in a timely manner, who is the federal government to tell them how to run their business? We are heading down a path that leads the U.S. deeper into the abyss of irreparable indebtedness, perpetual bureaucracy and an ineffective, paternalistic federal government.

 

Guy Jones

Nov 5, 2009

Correction for my post above. The first sentence should read "...every dollar in premiums received by insurance companies..." to my post above.

 

Dick Nixon

Nov 5, 2009

Check out page 24 of the bill for a good laugh:
"(6) LIMITING PROGRAM EXPENDITURES.—The
Secretary shall, with respect to the program—
(A) establish procedures to protect against
fraud, waste, and abuse under the program;
and
(B) provide for other program integrity
methods.
---------
Hilarious. If Congress could eliminate "waste, fraud and abuse" so easily, why hasn't it been done with respect to Medicare and SS?

 

Archie Moore

Nov 5, 2009

Someone who has knowledge of the new 1,900 bill, please answer this question: does the bill truly mandate through "medical loss ratios" that insurers spend 85 cents of every premium dollar on care? This sounds like a blatant attempt to push these companies into insolvency so that the "public option" is left standing as the sole option for care. So much for increasing competition.

 

aaCharley

Nov 5, 2009

Would being thrown out of the Health Care Exchange mean that Congress People would not be able to buy from those companies? If so, they will be enrolled in a Public Plan very very soon.

 

bill carson

Nov 5, 2009

The public knew that Obama intended to implement what most people would call socialized medicine. The American people gave all political power to Democrats. Now, it is time for the people to pay the price for such outlandish foolishness!

 

Joe

Nov 5, 2009

Your doing a heck of a job there Bronie.. err Pelosi. Just keep working on it at least it gives them something to do. It will NEVER pass

 

olddog

Nov 5, 2009

Why will federal employees' be allowed to keep the plans provided by the private insurance carriers? There is very little difference between the plans that are available to the public and the plan options that federal employees have every November during "open enrollment". After they pass "Obamacare" the only way you'll be able to have a comprhensive health insurance plan is if you work for the federal government!

 

Patty

Nov 5, 2009

Should this surprise anyone??? I think not!! They want the bill so long that no one reads the darn thing. They want all of us to shut up and follow along like lemmings. When I'm reading only 2% of the uninsured is going to be able to take advantage of it then I say why even have the thing. This is just another way for the government to take over some and have it fail miserably, examples are Amtrack, Medicare and the Post office. Get a grip everyone and vote out these people who do not speak for us in 2010.

 

depaz

Nov 6, 2009

If Congress was really concerned about "waste, fraud, and abuse" 90% of them would resign. . . . .

 

Tracie

Nov 6, 2009

These people wouldn't know the truth if it was a mack truck and ran over them... all they want is to have their thumb on WE THE PEOPLE!!! MORE control, less freedom...GET THEM OUT--2010/2012.

 

Michael Hampton

Nov 6, 2009

As long as you keep voting for career politicians, in either party, this is what you're going to get. Our government wasn't meant to be run by such people, but by ordinary Americans.

 

Michael Konkel

Nov 6, 2009

Sad part about all of this is that the health bill is part two of their grand scheme...health bill will ultimately drive the vast majority of all Americans to the government plan (read public option) but what no one is talking about is that the rationing boards, whatever you want to call them have been authorized, their chair has been authorized and they are well under way, thanks to the stimulus bill which no one read...these people will electronically visit patient records and advise doctorcs accordingly in line with bioethicist, ol' Zeke Emanuel (Rahm's brother) recommendations. Zeke has this 15 year old - 40 year old chart which shows that range to be the effective range of where medical money should go....seniors, tots, preteens, teens, you better not have issues..no one is going to carry you for a life time....seniors will have paid in the most and will lose the most.

Thank you our pinko president.

http://www.fortwaynevoiceoftruth.blogspot.com

 

junglejim123

Nov 6, 2009

Elections have consequences and I pray that all of those who shoved this Kenyan born fraud down our throats get paid back for the evil they have inflicted on us with this man and his vile associates. The day after the election the Illinois lottery tried to tell us something when the numbers came up as 666. Now its very clear that someone was trying to show us what we had done..

 

Same

Nov 7, 2009

everyone should just admit that this country is un-governable and while health care insurance reform is a nice idea, nothing worthwhile will ever be passed.

 

Jane

Nov 8, 2009

why dont the goverment stop paying for people to lay up and have babies then give them medicare for the babies so they dont have to pay a dime my town is booming with girls as young as 13 having babies and guess who will pay for it? not their parents but the tax payers

 

Nike mm

Dec 22, 2009

ggggxcgAir Max 360
kobe bryant shoes
Nike Kobe 4
Nike Kobe 5
Air Max 90
Air Max 1
North Face Jacket
North Face

 

onebutler

Dec 24, 2009

If the members of Congress and the President himself have not read 2000 pages of the Health Care Bill, they shouldn't even be allowed to discuss it, much less vote on it.

 

ugg-ク zsm

Dec 27, 2009

UGG Classic Mini
UGG クラシックミニ
UGG Classic Tall
UGG クラシックトール
UGG Classic ShortNorth Face Jacket
North Face
The North Face
Discount North Face
Cheap North Face Jacket
Cheap North Face

 

ugg zsm

Dec 27, 2009

ugg shoes
cheap ugg boots
uggs shoes
bailey button uggs
ugg classic
uggs 5803
ugg 5803North Face Jacket
North Face
The North Face
Discount North Face

 

timberland zsm

Dec 27, 2009

Womens Roll-Top Boots
Womens High Top Boots
Womens 6 Inch Boots
Mens Custom Boots
Mens Chukka Boots
North Face

 

Nike zsm

Dec 27, 2009

Nike Kobe IV
Lebron James Shoes
Lebron James Shoes
nike basketball shoes
air max 2009
North Face Jacket

 

john

Dec 28, 2009

i bet we could get this health bill done if it was for everyone including the goverment not just the tax payers

 

asder

Jan 2, 2010

Thanks for your useful info, I think it's a good topic
çizgi film
kayu çizgi filmini izle
çizgi film izle
caillou izle
gece bahçesi izle

 

Jan 11, 2010

projeksiyon

 

MahNoor

Jan 23, 2010

i agree with Mr.LarryD.

Live TV online
Dish TV online

Online TV

 


Post a comment


Email:
(This will not be displayed or shared. Privacy Policy)

Your Name:

Comment:




Local

Another snowball fight planned for Dupont Circle

The Official Dupont Circle Snowball Fight facebook fanpage has over 6,000 fans now, and it looks as if snowed in DC'ers will return for another battle. Full story

Politics

GOP winning war over Miranda rights for terrorists

Even as the administration defends its decision to grant accused Detroit bomber Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab the right to remain silent, the president himself is hinting that things might be done differently in the future. Full story

Local

D.C. region braces for up to 20 more inches of snow

The National Weather Service has the entire D.C. metro area, from Prince William County north, under a winter storm warning for 10 to 20 inches of snow. Forecasters have had their eyes on this storm for days, but the projected snow totals were bumped up late Monday. Full story