Obama and the Softening of America
By: Meghan Cox Gurdon
Examiner Columnist | 10/23/08 10:03 AM
When the Princess of Wales died beside her Egyptian lover in a car crash in Paris 11 years ago, Britain erupted with demonstrations of bizarre and desperate grief.
Huge mawkish heaps of teddy bears suffocated the gates of Buckingham Palace; floral bouquets smothered the surface of a little island at the princess’s family home.
Stiff upper lips wobbled as, with a great bawling the British populace collapsed in orgiastic mourning for the beautiful, lost “people’s princess.”
Not everyone joined in. The more contained, traditionally stoic types walked bewildered amongst their ululating countrymen. The Royal Family was denounced for its unfeeling continence, its inability to engage in the American-style displays of naked emotion that the British people suddenly seemed to expect.
That was the great weirdness of Diana’s departure: Subtle alterations had been taking place for many years in the British people, a great softening had been at work. Yet no one realized quite how dead Edwardian Britain was — or Churchillian Britain, for that matter — until Diana herself died.
Then, the weeping multitudes laying handwritten poems at makeshift shrines could not be mistaken any longer for those doughty survivors of the London Blitz. That old Britain was gone.
That’s what it’s starting to feel like, here in America.
The ascension of Barack Obama has laid bare the stunning extent of our own softening, the distance we’ve traveled from the people we once were.
Americans are responding to Obama not as though he is a political aspirant for an executive post that was once George Washington’s, but as a bringer of light and healing, as a kind of secular savior.
To facilitate this reverence, or perhaps because he can’t help it, the Illinois lawgiver forever tilts his jaw upwards, as if he’s tuning into frequencies from Mount Olympus.
We’ve had celebrities singing, indie-pop style, in praise of Obama. We’ve had black schoolboys marching, fascist style, in praise of Obama. We’ve had fresh-faced children singing and chanting, kumbaya-style, in praise of Obama.
And now, to the strains of a song to Jesus, you are asked to “Prepare your heart to fill with hope.” Thus saith a new campaign entitled “ManifestBarack.org,” which is urging us all, via YouTube, to spend a moment every day concentrating fiercely on making Obama’s potential victory a reality.
“Your vision is a sacred trust…You are the sanctuary…of a sacred vision…for a renewed America.” In between each phrase, smiling Americans say, “President Barack Obama,” as if he already is. They are Manifesting him. “Say it…Feel it…” we’re told, “Believe it.”
The vast rallies, the fainting, the tingling up journalists’ legs – it’s all very exciting but as the election approaches it is looking more than ever like mass hysteria.
It’s not a question of wanting one’s guy to win, it’s Believing. Obama doesn’t have a set of policy proposals, he has a sacred vision – and you are its sanctuary!
Eleven years ago, 10 days after Diana expired, while Britain was convulsed with hitherto unexpressed emotion, the editors of National Review warned: “Personal charisma is a force that undermines institutions as often as it sustains them.”
Not surprisingly, those editors were amongst the few starchy, tearless onlookers. Their insights then have unnerving resonance now, as our own country is half-convulsed by freakishly unprecedented political sentiments.
“Mass emotionalism and febrile celebrity-worship are hostile to any long-standing constitutional system, which, with the passage of time, is bound to seem stuffy as well as solid, remote as well as impressive, and archaic as well as historical,” the editors wrote.
“We must hope then, that the unhealthy emotions of the last ten days in both London and the American media are something we will look back on with embarrassment and shame – as if we had been gorging on melodrama.”
Oh, we will all be gorging on melodrama, whether the god Obama wins or loses.
Not everyone is joining in – certainly not Joe the Plumber – but like Diana-adoring Britons, Obama-loving Americans have shrugged off the old bounds of what is politically seemly.
Their emotional video paeans, quasi-religious songs, and ranks of chanting schoolchildren reveal just how far many Americans have traveled from the white-wigged temperance of our republic’s Founders.
Examiner columnist Meghan Cox Gurdon is a former foreign correspondent and a regular contributor to the books pages of The Wall Street Journal. Her Examiner column appears on Thursdays.
32 Comments




Reader Comments:
POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Gregory: "Its amazing how you glorify a lying, tax evading charlatan like Joe the Plumber and vilify the ascension of Barack Obama saying he has laid bare the stunning extent of our own softening. And to have the nerve to compare the love for Princess Diana as a weakness! The length you and this neo-con rag will take to defeat Mr. Obama is disturbing and quite frankly, alarming."POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Americans Hardening Against GOP Incompetence: "Gurdon of couse underestimates how fed up Americans are with Republicans and their unbelieveable incompetence. What we're seeing is actually 100 percent opposite of any softening. We're witnessing a hardening of Americans against the lies and disasters that have characterized the Republicans attempt to achieve a Permanent Republican Majority -- at any cost -- over the past decade or so. Obviously Obama is inspiring, although his following is not as cultish and blind to reality as Reagan Worship, which is practiced widely by the right wing and GOP in general, even though Reagan presided over a large increase in government and a big increase in federal debt. It's funny -- this is what the Republicans are left with: criticizing Obama because he is popular. You never heard Democrats use that lame logic against Reagan."POSTED Oct 23, 2008
: "Thanks goodness for the internet. Ruppard Murdock can't control it - yet. He owns the Wall Street Journal and has his hand in this rag too."POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Bruno Strozek: "Good Christ, I hope that your thesis is not true. If it is, we're a doomed people."POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Mahon: "What exactly do you propose as an example of Republican incompetence? Winning a necessary war in Iraq? Driving Al Queda back into the caves of Pakistan? Running a stable, growing economy until Reid and Pelosi took over two years ago? Proposing sensible reforms of Socal Security and Fannie and Freddie only to be blocked by Democrats? What can you possible mean by "an any cost" that compares to the massive vote fraud, stunning violations of the campaign finance laws, and common thuggery that characterize the Obama campaign?"POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Robbins Mitchell: "The political style and rhetorical devices that Baroque Obozo uses to mesmerize the chumps brings to mind an old Eddie Arnold song..."Cattle Call""POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Buford Gooch: "Ick!"POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Just Me: "ManifestObama.org has been removed. Apparently even the Obamanauts were embarrassed. Oh, and Gregory - you're insane. Some random guy is approached by Obama and speaks "truth to power", and this makes him evil?"POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Dean: "All these comments about "Joe the Plumber". Kill the questioner... Don't focus on Obama's "I want to spread the wealth"... No, no. You have to attack a guy that asked Obama a question. That's what we have to look forward to if Obama gets elected."POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Ed: "What? Do you not believe? Blasphemy! Heretic! Infidel! Away with him!"POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Luke: "The GOP has been incompetent, no doubt, as has the entire Congress. But what's the fantasy about "Permanent Republican Majority"? The GOP is not the party that started or perfected the gerrymandering that weakened the foundational structure of our republic by making "safe" districts, protecting party monopoly, and insulating bad ideas and bad politicians from ideological competition - all of which virtually guaranteed 40+ years of Dem-party domination in Congress. Please. Totally apart from that, though, you have to admit that it might be possible that some people find all this fruitcake talk about Obama being a "light worker" and a "savior" a bit New-Agey. It's weird. And more than a bit unseemly. No harm in noticing that. Oh, and you're right, the fact that the Left couldn't impeach Reagan because he was so popular never bothered them. Not at all. Never. Perish the thought. Just like Clinton didn't have the same effect on Republicans. Of course not. sheesh."POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Rob: "The blind hatred for Joe the Plumber - a Doubting Thomas to Obama's messiah role - is an indication of the depth of the mania. Joe was playing football in his yard with his son when Obama walked up, foot-canvassing the neighborhood. Now he is feverishly deemed a "plant" or a "charlatan". Apparently not drinking the Kool-Aid can get someone in serious trouble."POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Madison: "Obama, if elected, will be the American Idol President."POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Chip: "Well done. "...tuning into frequencies from Mount Olympus." Ha ha ha ha ha. That's a good one! The Egyptians painted all their royals gazing at the horizon. That's what it reminds me of. I loved this piece. Especially enjoyed the alacrity with which it is condemned, precisely proving the point to the post. Made me laugh aloud. Gregory, what's amazing is how badly you can misread a simple post, and the urgency you feel in projecting your own wrong reading. Ha ha ha ha ha. My fellow electorate are loons. But, how I do adore you little numbskulls."POSTED Oct 23, 2008
deek: "YOU MAKE A GRAVE MISTAKE IN MOCKING DEAREST LEADER. DEAREST LEADER IS MAKING A LIST AND CHECKING IT TWICE. DOUBLEPLUS UNGOOD!"POSTED Oct 23, 2008
MarkJ: "Umm, Greg. How do you figure "Joe the Plumber" is a charlatan? All Joe did was ask a direct question to The Anointed One. Of course, for you, that question was "wrong" because Obama then screwed up and actually told Joe what he really believes. How inconvenient, huh?"POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Pat in Colorado: ""Ruppard Murdock" (sic) has absoultely nothing to do with the Examiner. Rupert Murdoch either."POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Rolf: "Get real!"POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Derek: "How could any eduacted person try and pass of this nonsense as journalism or opinion? Honestly Ms. Gurdon did you just make up pheonomena (this idea of the "softening" of the American/British populations) and add a few offensive observations, and call it an opinion piece? George W. Bush's administration has been an international embarassment and the American people have the right to rejoice at the idea of an intelligent, competent, and likable president. After the Iraq War, 2 recessions, Katrina, the politicization of the Justice Department etc etc, haven't we earned it?"POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Barely About Barack: "Celebrity worship preceded Princess Diana. Heck, it preceded Ronald Reagan, John F. Kennedy, Andrew Jackson, and even George Washington. What are Gurdon and the National Review going on about? When did this "softening" begin, exactly? After Jesus died?"POSTED Oct 23, 2008
apb: "Gregory, you moron - This was about you, and you can't even see it. "Joe" merely asked a simple question that made your messiah look a stooge - and for being his acolyte, you're obviously dumber than dirt."POSTED Oct 23, 2008
BarryD: ""You never heard Democrats use that lame logic against Reagan." Were you alive in the 1980s?!?"POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Fred Kite: "Superb article. I was in London at the time and you caught the mood exactly. The parallels are uncanny. Obama is politics as therapy for liberals. He is a kind of wish fulfilment fantasy."POSTED Oct 23, 2008
Americans Hardening Against GOP Incompetence:: "McCain trashes Bush in today's Washington Times for Bush's incompetence. Do I need to repeat that? McCain. Trashes Bush Legacy. In Right Wing Litter Box The Washington Times. The size of the debt. Medicare programs that aren't paid for. The conduct of the war. Read it yourselves. http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2008/oct/23/mccain-lambastes-bush-years/print/ And then stop belly-aching about Democrats complaining about Bush and the Republicans. The truth? You can't handle the truth. Is there anything the Republicans HAVE NOT screwed up? The D's did not bash Reagan because he was POPULAR. There were way too many good reasons, no need for a silly one. But the GOP has nothing left to throw at Obama. Nothing except increasingly idiotic statements."POSTED Oct 24, 2008
Lianne: "Actually, a lot of Brits are embarassed by the melodramatic excesses of the Diana episode - witness the modest numbers who turned out for the 10th anniversary celebrations and their unhysterical demeanor. As to Obama and the religious fervor of many adherents (supporters is an inadequate term), they might think about adopting a genuine religion instead of worshipping false gods. As the Democratic Iowa farmer quoted during the primaries said, "I have a Messiah, I'm voting for the President of the United States.""POSTED Oct 24, 2008
Barely About Barack: "Fred Kite said, "I was in London at the time and you caught the mood exactly. The parallels are uncanny. Obama is politics as therapy for liberals. He is a kind of wish fulfilment fantasy." I think I see the problem. When THEY do it, it's wish fulfillment fantasy and celebrity worship that has little to do with policies. When WE do it, it's justified. Solipsim confirmed."POSTED Oct 24, 2008
jc: "The other day, I passed a restaraunt in my old neighborhood that repainted the exterior white so they could then paint a huge portrait of Obama. I thought to myself, " Why does this look so familiar?" Then it hit me. It reminded me of Iraq when I arrived in early 2003. Every where you looked there was a painting of Sadaam Hussein on every building.It's scary that our country has reached the point where we want a "king". I will not be responsible for this when I cast my vote for Chuck Baldwin."POSTED Oct 24, 2008
william: "I think he tilts his jaw up like Benito Mussolini. He also thinks like Il Duce."POSTED Oct 24, 2008
WILLIAM: "Derek: 'Ask 25 million Iraqis how they feel about George Bush. And did you miss 5 years of unprecednted growth, low unemployment, low inflation, etc.? Also Derek, what happened to the Polosi-Reid 100 hours to reduce gasoline prices and reform Congress?"POSTED Oct 24, 2008
McCain Slams Bush in Wash Times and Of Course Iraqis Love Our Dollars --: "Of course Iraqis love our $10 Billion a month spending in Iraq while they pile up profits. Who would have a problem with that? Maybe we should invade North Korea and prop up their economy too. McCain outlines the Bush disaster in yesterday's Washington Times -- he completely slams George W. Bush's record in the White House. So even McCain has finally come around to the truth. So why didn't he run against Bush 4 years ago?!"POSTED Oct 24, 2008
mary: ""Mass emotionalism and febrile celebrity worship"? Yeah - over Sarah Palin. We're acting like we're voting in a high school popularity contest."POSTED Oct 24, 2008
Canadian Goose: "In Canada we went through this process with the ascension of Pierre Elliot Trudeau. We are still trying to recover from the massive debt, increase in government size and a charter of rights that only makes lawyers rich."