By: Newt Gingrich
Reader Comments
PaulCC
Jul 3, 2009
As much as I agree with the Court's ruling on reverse discrimination, I cannot believe the test was totally unbiased or that everyone had an opportunity to review pre-test material much like what is available for many career positions. Not ONE black applicant passed??? Either the test was unfair or the applicants that took the test were not prepared well enough for it. I believe it was the latter. The question New Haven should have asked and answered (not the supreme court) was why it happened in the first place. Better pre-test assistance to ALL applicants might have improved the outcome. We will never know for sure. Who knows, if it was offered, it might have given the white and Hispanic applicants an even more lopsided advantage if black applicants didn't take advantage of the training opportunity.
CS
Jul 3, 2009
Why is the "assumption" if a representative from every race doesn't pass a test that it is the test or "the system" that failed someone? Who said that "ALL applicants" didn't have the same opportunity? What about the person who didn't take personal initiative, who choose not to spend their own time and or resources to prepare themselves for the test? The assumption is that everyone in America except "white people" are victims. What I want to know is what is a "white person"? By suggesting your assumptions are fact, you reinforce this victim mentality, perpetrating the myth that individuals bear no responsibility in taking control of their lives/ their careers, and infer that every test is a racially challenging event.
Sharon JV
Jul 5, 2009
I respectfully disagree with those who would claim that the firefighter test itself is discriminatory. I do believe over the years we've given the black community permission to feel entitled by granting more and more welfare of one kind or another. They appear to think they really don't have to earn a passing test score legitimately. I live in a community with a large percentage of blacks and have seen this attitude grow over the past 30 or so years. I am hugely encouraged by the supreme court decision on the firefighters in New Haven. Everyone will be safer and happier knowing civil servants truly earned a passing grade on their application test ... and not a watered down version of a good test.
Pam P
Jul 6, 2009
I firmly believe there is a great deal of reverse discrimination in this country. I'm not responsible for what my ancestors did or if they owned slaves, but caucasians are held responsible by all or most black folk. My husband applied for the police department in our county, and was well qualified. He was a Marine MP and assigned to Marine One, however, because he is not black or female, he was passed over for quota. Is this the american way, is everone considered equal?
Post a comment
Sports
ITF says it will uphold 1-year ban for Belgian tennis players Wickmayer, Malisse
The International Tennis Federation has confirmed a one-year suspension for Belgian tennis players Yanina Wickmayer and Xavier Malisse. Full story
Politics
House Democrats clear impasse over abortion holding up vote on health care legislation
Capping months of months of struggle, House Democrats cleared an abortion-related impasse blocking a vote on sweeping health care legislation late Friday and officials expressed optimism they had finally lined up the support needed to pass President Barack Obama's top domestic priority. Full story
Entertainment
'Golden Girls' star McClanahan has bypass surgery
Rue McClanahan, who played sexy Southern belle Blanche Devereaux on "The Golden Girls," was recovering Thursday from heart bypass surgery at a New York City hospital. Full story


