Sports

[Print]  [Email]        

Rick Snider » Vick would spice things up

By: Rick Snider
Examiner Sports Columnist
January 4, 2009

If fans aren’t happy with how Jason Campbell played in 2008, perhaps Michael Vick would give the Redskins offense a boost. (Getty images)
It’s never too early to debate who’s quarterbacking the Redskins next season.

If Jason Campbell isn’t the answer, many fans want to skip over aging Todd Collins for Colt Brennan. The hero of the Hawaiian Islands reminded me of Sonny Jurgensen during the preseason with his playmaking ability.

But let’s play hot stove league all the way. There’s a free agent passer coming loose on Jan. 20 that might help the Redskins. Someone who can play wildcat formation with the best.

Michael Vick.

OK, before e-mailing me a string of expletives, let’s think about it a minute. Vick is expected to be released from federal prison on Jan. 20 to a Virginia halfway house after serving 14 months for conspiracy charges relating to a dogfighting gambling ring. He’ll reportedly be sent to a halfway house near his family in the Tidewater area. Who’s to say he can’t come closer to Ashburn should employment loom?

There’s also the problem of being re-instated by the NFL. Vick has missed two seasons. That’s one year longer than Alex Karras missed over gambling. Commissioner Roger Goodell has been fair with problem players before. Two years seems long enough.

How would fans react? Certainly, there would be a major backlash. Dog fighting brings an emotional response from people. Certainly, if someone stole my golden retriever to use in a dog fight I might do something rash to them. They’re more than animals to many people, they’re part of our family.

But, when do we forgive someone who has been punished? Was 14 months in prison and the loss of millions of dollars in salary and endorsements sanction enough? Some people say there is never forgiveness, but everyone deserves a second chance. If playing football is what Vick does for a living, then he should have the right to do so.

Everyone assumes Vick will head to Oakland because many of the league’s troubled players go to the Raiders. And, maybe he will. But, any team needing a quarterback should at least review Vick. He might even play receiver.

Most general managers don’t want the headaches. However, the Redskins don’t really have a general manager. Owner Dan Snyder makes the calls and if he wants Vick, there’s nobody to stop him.

I’m not saying the Redskins should sign Vick. He would have to be the right fit for the offense and still have something left after two seasons away. But, Vick’s talent is unquestionable and certainly he could help a 19th-ranked offense.

When trying to figure ways over the offseason to upgrade a team mired in mediocrity with a quarterback who hasn’t won over fans in four years, it’s worth a discussion.

Something tells me the debate over Vick’s future will make the past presidential race look civil.

Rick Snider has covered local sports since 1978. Read more at TheRickSniderReport.com or e-mail rsnider@dcexaminer.com.




Redskins Confidential

...Linebacker H.B. Blades will be a game-time decision, less than two weeks after undergoing arthroscopic surgery. Earlier in the week, the Redskins did not anticipate he would...

One of these days we'll actually get back to writing and discussing football at Redskins Park. One of these days they may give you a reason to do just that. Today was not one of...

Falcons coach Mike Smith, a rookie coach like Jim Zorn last year, talked about why he's had a lot of early success in Atlanta. It differs from Zorn's experience in Washington....

...Coach Jim Zorn said Antwaan Randle El will be deep on the first punt return vs. Atlanta, but that DeAngelo Hall and Santana Moss would also return punts. It's the same...


To view this site, you need to have Flash Player 8.0 or later installed. Click here to get the latest Flash player.


Most Popular Headlines



 


 



 

Reader Comments

All comments on this page are subject to our Terms of Use and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Examiner or its staff. Comment box is limited to 250 words.

Atlanta Seminole

Jan 4, 2009

Can we start the string of expletives?

 

ypayne

Jan 4, 2009

I am glad somebody is finally rising above the irrational hysteria. Hopefully this saga regarding Vick and the abuse of those dogs is over. Its time to move on. If others who have done much than Vick, such as taking another humans life, can be forgiven and allowed to continue their career, then their is no justification for not allowing Vick to continue his career. Whoever signs Vick will not be disappointed. Vick will be much better than he was before he entered prison because he has something to prove to "himself", family members and most of all to those who mocked him. Hopefully others will begin to show some "commonsense" as you have demonstrated.

 

David

Jan 4, 2009

Sorry, that's the stupidest suggestion I've read in a long time. No way the Redskins sign Vick. If they do I'll give you my right arm.

 

NotOakland

Jan 4, 2009

He won't go to Oakland because that's where many of his went to dogs live. Oakland doesn't want him. Face it, he's ruined. Maybe he can switch sports. NHL?

 

Umbra

Jan 4, 2009

I agree totally. The Redskins SHOULD sign the dude...he will be a lot better then Jason Campbell and boost their offense to top 10 easy.

 

J4S5Fan

Jan 4, 2009

If Vick plays for the Skins, I'm done with the team completely.

 

Dogfan

Jan 4, 2009

Maybe Pete Rose can sign again with the Reds to be their manager and maybe Rae Carruth (that Carolina Panther player who killed his girlfriend)can start for the Panthers if they make the Super Bowl.

 

a.turtle

Jan 4, 2009

When you separate the emotional from the practical, Vick with the Redskins makes a whole lot-o-sense.

 

chockoe

Jan 4, 2009

Two words....COLT BRENNAN...Give him some time but he is the real deal

 

Georgia

Jan 4, 2009

Marley & Me just broke box office records. You must be kidding to think Vick/Ookie will EVER stop being a liability to any team that signs him. The NFL should ban all felons for life. But especially Ookie because his crime was so heinous and took place for over 8 years. It is time for there to be real sports heroes like Michael Jordan again. Get rid of all the Pacmans and the Vicks permanently. Otherwise the NFL is teaching kids that they can commit ANY crime, and still be paid millions. No felon should be in a position of being a public figure. Enough with the thugs. Vick/Ookie can get a job washing cars. At least he wasn't shot,hung,electrocuted, or crushed for losing his endorsements. Unlike his dogs that he killed after losing fights.

 

YES!!

Jan 5, 2009

Why not? It's not like Vick is gonna go for a multi year cap busting contract. He'll only get one year and probably between 1-3 million at the very most. It's a risk the Redskins should be willing to take. If not at QB, then as a guy who can come in every once in a while and provide the big play(ex: Brad Smith, Troy Smith, Josh Cribbs). He'll be a fan favorite simply because he's from Virginia. It makes sense to me. For all the haters, open your heart and forgive this man. There's no point in hatin and holding a grudge. The past is the past. I'm rooting for Vick to comeback, be a better man and become a star once again.

 

Jan 5, 2009

"He'll be a fan favorite simply because he's from Virginia." You're kidding, right? Snyder isn't that stupid; he'd lose more fans ($) than he'd gain. Don't forget, many of Vick's dogs came from Virginia and ended up in Virginia, especially the Tidewater area. If Vick goes to the 'Skins, I won't be making the trip to FedEx field again.

 

Kyle Burch

Jan 7, 2009

hi I am a big redskins fan and i think you should sign hem befor other teams do and sign marques vick to + in the draft get james larunitis in the first round in third get alex boone cool

 

CP26

Jan 11, 2009

I certainly agree with you if Jason Campbell does not get the job done I think Vick will be a good fit. I understand the guy gets in trouble but come on Ray Lewis was tried for a murder charge no one question that... Micheal Vick should get another chance

 

DON POLO

Jan 11, 2009

Finally Dan is thinking. Signing Vick will bring me back to watching games at Fed Ex and not at home.We really need him because he's more than a QB that could help out our Offense.And Campbell is not the answer.

 

tom

Feb 24, 2009

Michael vick should go to the Skins. Jason the QB needs to stop playing around and get serioud. All the haters stop hating he's coming back. The past is the past stop hating.

 

JETSsetter

Mar 31, 2009

I think Vick would be an assett to either your Skins of my Jets. He might be bound for Oakland but hopefully he stays on the East. I know what he did was wrong but he did his time and paid his dues now let the man play the game he was born to play.

 

D.RoB

Apr 5, 2009

REDSKINS PLEASE SIGN VICK!!!!! He is just what we need at QB...he has paid his dues and everybody deserves another chance. Why? Jesus says so...look it up yourself! To all you fairweather fans that would leave...GOODBYE! And I guess I should be expecting arms in the mail pretty soon! ;-)

 

JB

Apr 7, 2009

Vick will be a great addition we have no line at all and Vick has the physical ability to make plays with his feet and arm with the help of Santana, Clinton, and Cooley this could be an scary offense

 

the heart of dc

May 21, 2009

i feel that vick should come to dc and we should release collins in the order of playing time micheal vick jason campbell colt brennan that will be great think bout it speed speed and speed did i say speed back field clinton portis qb micheal vick TE chris cooley 1WR santana moss 2wr marvin harrison opps sorry antwaan randle el 3wr devin thomas thats too much a team can handle REDSKINS PLEASE PICK MICHEAL VICK UP

 

S.Dot

May 27, 2009

Thanks D.Rob to all you fairweather fans kick rocks. Send your arms next day delivery, because Vick SkinsD=Conference Championship:)And then.....Super Bowl....hahahah

 


Post a comment


Email:
(This will not be displayed or shared. Privacy Policy)

Display Name:

Comment:




Sports

Phil Mickelson of the United States, right, walks as his compatriot Tiger Woods looks on the 18th hole during the final round of the HSBC Champions golf tournament at the Sheshan International Golf Cl...

Phil Mickelson stages late rally to beat Ernie Els in HSBC Champions, as Tiger Woods falters

Phil Mickelson won the HSBC Champions on Sunday by rallying against a familiar foe. Only it wasn't Tiger Woods. Full story

Politics

Demonstrators chant on Capitol Hill in Washington, Thursday, Nov. 5, 2009, during a Republican health Care reform rally. (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana)

House Democrats clear impasse over abortion holding up vote on health care legislation

Capping months of months of struggle, House Democrats cleared an abortion-related impasse blocking a vote on sweeping health care legislation late Friday and officials expressed optimism they had finally lined up the support needed to pass President Barack Obama's top domestic priority. Full story

Entertainment

'Golden Girls' star McClanahan has bypass surgery

Rue McClanahan, who played sexy Southern belle Blanche Devereaux on "The Golden Girls," was recovering Thursday from heart bypass surgery at a New York City hospital. Full story