<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="http://b.scorecardresearch.com/p?c1=2&amp;c2=15743189&amp;cv=2.0&amp;cj=1&amp;&amp;c5=&amp;c15=">

# A modest pro-family tax policy: Index marginal rate thresholds to family size

My friend, AEI colleague, and fellow Catholic dad Ramesh Ponnuru writes that the GOP should expand the child tax credit as a pro-middle-class, pro-family policy. Maybe. I’m not big on tax credits, but I agree we should have some more pro-family tax policy. So here’s my idea:

The tax brackets should get wider as your family grows.

Let me begin my explanation by pointing out two facts about our tax code currently:

1) I get six times the personal exemption of a single person, because I have a wife and four kids. A single person’s first \$4,000 is tax free (\$3,900 technically, but I’m going to round it off for simplicity’s sake). My first \$24,000 is tax free. I think this is good.

2) A married couple gets to make twice as much money before being bumped from the 10% bracket into the 15% bracket — and then again for being bumped into the 25% bracket. So, a single woman starts paying 25% on every marginal dollar after \$36,250 in taxable income. A woman supporting her husband doesn’t start paying 25% until \$72,500 in taxable income. I think this is good, too.

So, as your household grows from one person to two, your tax brackets get twice as wide. But as your household grows beyond two (as you start having kids) the only “bracket” that gets wider is your “0% bracket” — that is, your personal exemption.

The chart below shows what I’m talking about. As your household grows past 2, the only color band to grow wider is the 0% bracket. The other thresholds get higher as family size grows, but only because the widening 0% bracket pushes them up.

Married with no kids, you get taxed at 25% on all income above \$72,500 in taxable income (which is total income minus exemptions and deductions). Married with six kids, and you still get taxed at 25% above \$72,500 in taxable income.

So, here’s my proposal: All brackets, not just the 0% bracket, should get wider as household size grows. If a single gets \$9,000 at the 10% rate, and a couple gets \$18,000 at the 10% rate, a couple with a kid should get an additional \$4,500 at that 10% rate (I’m counting kids as half an adult) for a total of \$22,500 at the 10% rate.

Here’s why. I see the rates in a progressive tax code this way: When you’re dirt poor, we don’t tax you at all. When you actually have a bit of money, but are still in poverty, we tax you at 10%. When you are out of poverty, but still not really enjoying luxuries, we take 15% of your money. Once you have a bit of a cushion, we take 25% of your money. As you get wealthy, we take a higher portion.

Well, the distance in income between those categories — poverty, basic needs met, a bit of a cushion — grows as you have more dependents. So the distance between the income-tax-rate thresholds should grow, too. Here’s what I’m suggesting it should look like:

You see, not only do the bracket thresholds get higher as your household expands, but the bracket bands get wider, too.

Pro-family tax policy without new credits!

• ##### The illusion of choice: Why Vladimir Putin will be czar of Russia for life
The only way for Putin to lose the upcoming election is by a miraculous liberation of Russia’s entire political process.
• ##### Trump's people on track to be every bit as wasteful with taxpayers dollars as any previous administration
President Trump was carried to victory in 2016 in part on the promise that he would rid the nation’s capital of grift, waste and abuse. Reports from just the last couple of weeks, however, suggest the president's own team is part of the problem.
• ##### Why I love St. Patrick's Day, even though I'm barely Irish
My love affair with Ireland and thus, St. Patrick’s Day, began in my teens, when I embraced the unconfirmed possibility I was at least one-quarter Irish. I loved the beautiful land, the fighting spirit of the people, the complex political and spiritual ramifications -- only one problem: I later figured out I'm even less Irish than I previously thought. Still, about the same time, I learned about the man behind St. Patrick’s Day, shared it with my children, and now we all love the holiday even more because it has significant meaning.
• ##### Stormy Daniels' extortion campaign gets red carpet rollout in the media
Here’s a mental exercise. Which is more obscene: President Trump teasing NBC’s Chuck Todd as a “sleepy son of a bitch” or all of the media participating in a porn actress’ sick career rehabilitation program?
• ##### Who is Iran's next target? Bahrain. Time for the US to draw a line in the sand
Bahrain, a Persian Gulf monarchy and the smallest Arab country, has an outsized role both in U.S. national security and, since 2011, in the criticism it has received in Congress, from the State Department, and from human rights organizations.
• ##### How many Parkland-related bills does Marco Rubio have to introduce to satisfy CNN's Alisyn Camerota?
CNN’s Alisyn Camerota did nothing to help her network get away from the “fake news” tag so often applied to it by President Trump when she launched a factually inaccurate and basically dishonest attack on Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla.
• ##### Sean Duffy: 'Of course' Democrats will impeach Trump if they regain control in midterms
A blue wave in November could be the end of President Trump's presidency, according to Rep. Sean Duffy, R-Wis.
• ##### In Illinois, even the campaign workers unionize
Unions are shrinking all across America. This is especially true in the private sector, where most younger workers find them irrelevant. But that doesn't mean the gig is up for unions. It just means that organizers have to become more creative.
• ##### For one day, Iranian people defy regime during annual festival
Two months after massive uprisings erupted across Iran, the ruling regime is still hard-pressed to re-establish its control over the country. The regime’s waning power was emphasized again on Tuesday when protesters poured to the streets on the occasion of Iran’s Fire Festival. Iran’s rulers have always been disdainful of the Fire Festival, an ancient Persian tradition that takes place on the last Tuesday before the Iranian New Year, during which people head outdoors to celebrate by jumping over small fires and lighting firecrackers and fireworks.
• ##### Patrick Morrisey takes lead in West Virginia senate race, blasts Evan Jenkins for spreading 'junk polling'
The most recent polling in the West Virginia Senate primary shows state Attorney General Patrick Morrisey in first place, encouraging the candidate to take a shot at his chief rival for spreading “junk polling.”
• ##### Wendy Davis might be the next president of Planned Parenthood
Given Davis' coy response to questions about replacing Cecile Richards, it's probably fair to say she's under consideration for the gig.
• ##### Pro Publica doesn't deserve a pat on the back merely for correcting its disastrously wrong CIA torture report
Praising Pro Publica for admitting this week that it made a massive, consequential mistake involving President Trump’s choice to lead the CIA is setting the bar especially low for the press.
• ##### Toys 'R' Us is closing because capitalism is awesome, so stop whining
On Thursday, Toys "R" Us announced that, after 70 years as the major toy chain, it was going defunct. Immediately there was a nostalgic backlash of adults humming the theme song, "I don’t wanna grow up, I’m a Toys ‘R’ Us kid…” to coincide with news reports of their closing.
• ##### If Russia expels British diplomats, Britain, France, Germany and the US should expel their Russian ambassadors
If Russia follows through on its foreign minister (and eloquent troll) Sergey Lavrov's threat, and expels British diplomats from Moscow, then Britain, France, Germany, and the U.S. should expel Russia's ambassadors to their capitals. Although that might seem like an excessive escalation, there are two reasons why it would be appropriate.
• ##### SEC deregulation can save trees and time
In 2015, the Securities and Exchange Commission suggested what is known as Rule 30e-3, which modernizes the way companies and mutual funds report disclosure reports to shareholders and the public. The idea: getting rid of the requirement to deliver a hard copy and moving to the option of sending these digitally. However, this change is now facing opposition from interest groups. It turns out that there indeed such a thing as a tree lobby, and it’s much stronger than you think.
• ##### Trump just did Dean Heller a solid by talking Danny Tarkanian out of the Nevada Senate race
Danny Tarkanian is out of the Nevada Senate race, but unfortunately not forgotten from politics.