Democratic strategist James Carville pushed back against the possibility of former President Joe Biden having a future in the Democratic Party, saying “the party’s moving on” from him.

A day before leaving the Oval Office, Biden said he was “not going anywhere” while encouraging people to “keep the faith in the better day to come,” hinting at a desire to continue playing a role in the Democratic Party. Carville, however, suggested that Biden needs to permanently retire, saying, “No one wants to hear from this guy anymore.”