A Washington Post headline teasing a possibly scandalous story about Marco Rubio being arrested in 1990 proved a big letdown for readers who expected something more shocking than a tale about an 18-year-old being caught in a park after dark.

“Marco Rubio was once in a public park after dark. I’m not kidding…that’s the ‘arrest.’ That’s it,” pollster Kristen S. Anderson said on social media.