In a short, powerful piece in National Review, Rick Brookhiser concludes that “the conservative movement is no more. Its destroyers are Donald Trump and his admirers.”
Looking around me in early 2018, I can’t disagree. This is cause for lament, and lament Brookhiser does, as I do. But in the midst of your sorrows, you of course realize: Movements grow old. They eventually die. Bill Buckley founded the American conservative movement in 1955. Can a political movement reasonably be expected to thrive and retain its vigor for more than 60 years, for more than three generations?
I’m reminded of Abraham Lincoln’s great speech on “The Perpetuation of Our Political Institutions,” delivered when he was 28 years old in 1838—slightly more than six decades after the American Revolution. Lincoln lamented the fact that the memories of the revolution were fading, and with them the attachment to its principles. The whole speech is worth reading for its power and subtlety, but here’s a key section:
Trump is the proximate, the efficient, cause of the collapse of the conservative movement. The principles of sound conservativism compel us to criticize him, to rebut him, to resist him, and to plan to overcome him. But, perhaps it is the “silent artillery of time” that has done the damage which Trump was able to take advantage of. And that suggests our task, the task of the descendants of the founders of American conservatism goes beyond that: It is to rebuild, or to build other pillars that will uphold the temple of American liberty in the 21st century.
Brookhiser suggests at the end of his piece, “It will take a lot of arguing to rebuild a conservative movement that one can contemplate without scorn.” True. And it will take a lot of work to create a new birth of conservatism—if it even is still called conservatism—that will support American freedom and greatness.