One of the worst trends in modern jurisprudence is that of higher court judges unnecessarily and timorously punting legal questions back to lower courts. Two judges on the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals did it again Wednesday, thus leaving Obamacare in constitutional limbo yet again. Their explanation for doing so was unsatisfactory.
The case, Texas v. U.S., involved a new challenge to the “individual mandate” in Obamacare. The mandate is the provision in that controversial law that was upheld by Chief Justice John Roberts in 2012, on flimsy grounds, because Roberts ruled it could be seen as a tax even though he admitted that was not its most ordinary interpretation. Roberts and a court majority agreed, though, that if it were not a tax, it would be unconstitutional.