In the last month, there have been several major surprises in the culture war over popular music. First, one of the music world’s most liberal magazines issued a blistering rebuke of rock’n’roll’s prevailing solipsism and spoiled-brat ethic. Then a respected classical-music critic published a ringing defense of nonclassical music in a distinguished conservative magazine. And a terrific new album was released that reclaims the positive, pre-punk rock’n’roll traditions. Taken together, these events bode well for those of us who are cultural conservatives but often are made to feel that we are somehow betraying the cause because we like pop music.
The broadside against rock came in the pages of Melody Maker, the British music weekly. The Maker is usually one of the most glib celebrants of rock excess, yet in his assessment of the new album by R.E.M. — forefathers of alternative rock and recent recipients of an $ 80 million deal with Warner Brothers — critic Paul Lester sounded like a schoolmarm scolding a recalcitrant child. After establishing that R.E.M.’s New Adventures in High-Fi is one long gripe about the “problems” of rock fame, Lester rejected the new album as nothing more than “a mean-spirited indictment of the system that has indulged [R.E.M.’s] every whim.” He called the band’s thirtysomething lead singer Michael Stipe “the oldest whining teenager in town,” who complains of his fame yet does everything in his power to cause scandal — in this case, by singing incendiary lyrics like “I can’t say that I love Jesus.” As for the sound of the band, Lester was unequivocal: Put on this album, and “feel gravity’s pull as you freefall onto your bed from boredom.”