One of the most oft-repeated criticisms of charter schools (and by, association, the whole idea of school choice) and is that they don’t perform as well, or at least any better than, their long-established traditional public school counterparts. “Evidence” of this argument is usually offered up in the form of carefully selected statistics from this or that study which “prove” the point. But often those numbers are skewed or isolated from other statistics or studies that tend to moderate such findings or prove them wrong entirely. A prime example comes from Florida, where a recent analysis of data for the 2015-2016 school year reveals that the state’s charter school students made greater learning gains than their peers in traditional public schools.
Yes, that’s correct. According to the Florida Department of Education’s just-released annual report on “Student Achievement in Florida’s Charter Schools: A Comparison of the Performance of Charter School Students with Traditional Public School Students,” the state’s charter schools present a very different picture from what critics would have you think. It also provides an impressive example of what can be achieved when a state fosters a school choice environment that allows opportunity and innovation to flourish. Here are some numbers: