“By Jeeves,” at 1st Stage, is a sprightly spoof of musicals, theatrical convention, overblown romanticism, British class distinctions and many things American. Inspired by the works of P.G. Wodehouse, with music by Andrew Lloyd Webber and book and lyrics by Alan Ayckbourn, in its best moments “By Jeeves” flashes tributes to the brilliance of Noel Coward and the silliness of Gilbert and Sullivan. Apart from those moments, it provides two hours of admirably frivolous fun. “By Jeeves” takes place in England about 1934. The central character, the rich but somewhat inept Bertie Wooster (Edward Nagel), is about to perform a banjo concert to benefit his church when his banjo disappears. As he always does when at a loss, Bertie turns to his ever-calm valet, Jeeves (Matt Dewberry) for advice, and Jeeves recommends that Bertie relate the story of a weekend adventure.
The relationship between Jeeves and Bertie is crucial to the musical, and Nagel and Dewberry make a tremendous team in this production. Jeeves is director, stage manager, prop master and prompter, drolly directing his “man” when Bertie absent-mindedly forgets what he is doing onstage. Nagel, who has a clear, sweet tenor voice, delivers some of the show’s best songs. Although he doesn’t sing much (his one patter song is delightful), Jeeves’ quiet, stable presence is an essential element of “By Jeeves.”