U.S. Army Gives ‘Condolence Payment’ to Family of Taliban Commander Killed by U.S. Forces

Last weekend, a U.S. raid in a region north of Kabul led to the killing of 15 Afghans. The local villagers and the Afghan government claimed all of those killed were civilians, while the United States said Taliban fighters, including a target leader, were among those killed. The incident, like many others in Afghanistan, has sparked an international uproar over the use of force in the Taliban-ridden country. But an Afghan counterterrorism official and the governor of the province where the raid took place admitted the Taliban leader and other Taliban fighters were among those killed in the attack. So what did the U.S. Army do in response to the raid and the resulting controversy? It issued payments to the families of those killed, including the Taliban commander. The Associated Press reports:

On the back of an Afghan army truck, U.S. officials paid $40,000 in Afghan currency to representatives of the 15 people killed – $2,500 for each death plus $500 for two wounded men and $1,500 for village repairs. Lt. Col. Steven Weir, a military lawyer who helped oversee the payments, said the payments were not an admission by the U.S. that innocents were killed. “It’s a condolence payment,” he said. “The villagers said none of them were in the Taliban, just peaceful individuals from the village. So by this payment they will understand it’s not our goal to kill innocent people. This may help them understand we’re here to build a safer and more secure Afghanistan.” When asked if the U.S. was paying money to relatives of people that the U.S. had wanted to kill or capture, Weir said: “If we did accidentally shoot someone, we want to make that right, and if we have to pay money to someone who didn’t deserve it … it’s kind of like it’s better to let nine guilty people go free than to jail one innocent person.”

But didn’t the Taliban commander “deserve it”? It’s just this kind of fuzzy logic that gets U.S. troops killed. The money given to the Taliban commander’s family will funneled back into the Taliban coffers–in fact, the odds are good the Taliban will move back into the town and collect all of the money disbursed–and used to facilitate attacks on U.S. troops.

Related Content