Ahundred and fifty years ago, James Mill, the father of John Stuart Mill, published an immense history of India, a country he’d never visited and whose languages he did not speak. Mill intended to expose to his readers the ignorance and backwardness of Indian culture; what he exposed instead was the narrowness and arrogance of his own mind. Ironically enough, Mill’s work is still read — not as a sourcebook on India, for on that subject it is and was nearly useless, but as a frightening manifestation of the rigidity of the Utilitarian philosophical tradition from which it sprang.
This fall, Oxford professor Felipe Fernandez-Armesto published to enthusiastic reviews in England a huge new history of the world that is interesting in exactly the same way James Mill’s book was. In just 816 pages, Fernandez-Armesto manages to display virtually every one of the prejudices and vices that have done so much to degrade the teaching of the humanities in our universities. Anyone in search of a solid one-volume summary of the planet’s history would do well to take his Christmas gift copy of Millennium: A History of Our Last Thousand Years (Scribner, $ 35) to a good used-book store and swap it for a copy of William H. McNeill’s Rise of the West or Hugh Thomas’s An Unfinished History of the World. But if you want to see the modern academic mind in all its self-congratulatory self-hatred, no book offers a more complete picture than Millennium.