House Dems: If You Can’t Beat ‘Em… Change the Rules

The rules of the House of Representatives give a committed majority a lot of power to push through legislation favored by the leadership. Most significant legislation is considered under ‘special rules’ designed to structure (or limit) debate. Contrary to their campaign promises to change the way Congress does business, Democrats have used such special rules to stifle debate and arrive at a pre-determined outcome — much the way Republicans did. But it seems that despite party discipline and stifled debate, Democrats are still managing to lose some votes. So today in the midst of a debate on the budget resolution — House Democrats will ‘go nuclear,’ in a way that Republicans never tried, and change a rule that has stood on the books since 1822. The Politico explained recently what the GOP is doing:

Democrats have been stingy about allowing Republican amendments to their bills early on, despite claims that they would be more inclusive, so GOP leaders have worked out a convenient loophole that allows them to amend these bills on the floor without working through the Rules Committee.
This is fairly insider stuff, but it does mean Republicans have found a vehicle to offer politically popular revisions to the bills Democrats bring to the floor. The goal is to either win the motion and amend the bill or put members of the majority on the record supporting something that will be used against them during their reelection campaigns in 2008.

This is a far cry from Ms. Pelosi’s promise last year that if Democrats took the majority, they would lose votes when a majority was against them. Almost exactly a year ago, Congress Daily reported:

In perhaps the biggest break from the current practices of GOP leaders, Pelosi said she would be willing to lose votes on the floor.
“Absolutely,” she said. “It’s not about a defeat, it’s about a decision. I certainly would not say that we can’t bring things to the floor because we’ll lose … [Republicans] are afraid of ideas.
That’s why we can’t have amendments, substitutes, and all the rest for the most part. When was the last time you ever saw a Democratic bill come to the floor of the House except to name a post office when they name five? It just doesn’t happen and that’s not right.”

It looks like the Democrats are really rushing this through before anyone can notice; while the House Rules Committee website is generally a pretty good place to find information on major votes upcoming in the House, this one is nowhere to be found. It’s been reported that Republican Leader Boehner had told his Democratic counterparts some time ago that any attempt to change such a longstanding rule would lead the GOP to tie the House floor in knots. We’ll see this afternoon whether they’ll make good on that promise.

Related Content