Air Force leaders want a huge buildup. But how will they pay for it?

CONFRONTING GREAT POWERS MEANS GREAT CHANGE: The Air Force’s announcement that it wants to add 74 new squadrons, a 25 percent increase in airpower, is one of the first signs the Pentagon is taking Defense Secretary Jim Mattis’ new National Defense Strategy to heart. In announcing the ambitious expansion — the largest since the Cold War — Air Force Secretary Heather Wilson cited the strategy’s shift from combating terrorism to confronting rising powers Russia and China, what Mattis calls the return to “great power competition.”

“We must see the world as it is. … We must prepare,” Wilson said in a speech at the Air Force Association’s Air, Space & Cyber Conference yesterday. “Less than a week ago Russia began the largest exercise on Russian soil in four decades, with more than 300,000 troops and 1,000 aircraft. On the other side of the world, China’s first aircraft carrier was declared combat ready this year, and promptly sailed into the Pacific to conduct flight operations.”

The Air Force, Wilson has argued since her first day on the job, is simply too small for what the nation expects of it, that the current 312 operational squadrons are not nearly enough. “What will it take? 386,” she said yesterday. “The Air Force we need to implement the National Defense Strategy has 386 operational squadrons.”

RETHINKING AIR WARFARE: Wilson said the Air Force will not just get bigger, but it will also fundamentally change the way it fights. At 10:45 a.m today, Chief of Staff Gen. David Goldfein is scheduled to outline how the Air Force will organize and train in order to create multiple dilemmas for its adversaries, when he speaks on day two of the conference at National Harbor, Md. The conference wraps up tomorrow with appearances from Deputy Defense Secretary Pat Shanahan, Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos and others.

IT’S GOING TO BE EXPENSIVE: There were no dollars attached to the plan to dramatically grow the size of the Air Force by the 2025 to 2030 timeframe, an initiative that will still have to be incorporated into President Trump’s budget and approved by Congress. But Todd Harrison, a budget expert with the Center for Strategic and International Studies, says his back-of-the-envelope calculations come up with about $13 billion as a rough estimate of the annual operation and maintenance costs. The required 40,000 additional personnel would add about $5 billion annually. And that, Harrison says, does not include the acquisition costs of buying the additional aircraft that would be needed.

“I think the challenge for the Air Force will be how to afford such a significant increase in size while it is also trying to modernize its capabilities. Doing both things — growing the force and modernizing the force — will require a significant budget increase on top of the big increase the Air Force already received this year,” Harrison told me yesterday. “By proposing such an ambitious plan without identifying offsetting cuts in lower priority aircraft and missions, the Air Force may be setting itself up for disappointment.”

CHANGE IS HARD: In an op-ed in the Washington Post, former Deputy Defense Secretary Robert Work and Elbridge Colby, who recently served as deputy assistant secretary of defense, wrote that the Pentagon must take big, bold steps to implement Mattis’ vision or risk losing the next war.

“The operational concepts that worked against Iraq in 1991 must be left in the past. We need to move away from the large and vulnerable ships, the fixed bases, and the short-range aircraft and munitions upon which we have long relied,” Work and Colby wrote.

“Such predictable and routinized operations might work against rogue nations, but they won’t work against the militaries of China or Russia. Instead, we must concentrate on building and maintaining a force capable of taking on and besting a top-tier adversary under the assumption that U.S. forces will be contested at every step by highly capable opponents.”

THE WORLD AS IT IS: At a CSIS event yesterday, Defense Intelligence Agency Director Lt. Gen. Robert Ashley underscored where his focus is. “So my aide told me that I should just get up here and say, ‘Great power competition, AI,’ drop the mic and walk off,” Ashley joked before launching into a discussion of how Russian President Vladimir Putin has worked to become a strategic competitor to the United States.

“The Russians were not strangers in Syria before the conflict, but part of when we talked about that great power competition, that is an opportunity for them to increase their presence in Syria whether it’s through airfields, ports, access in the Mediterranean,” Ashley said.

“For Putin is, you know, part of being a great power is that he sits at the table with other great powers. And so, that’s part of the intent behind what he wants to accomplish,” Ashley said. “We see that in Libya, we see that in Syria that they inject their presence. Therefore, he gets himself to the table in some way, shape, or form to make a decision.”

RUSSIA, TURKEY AGREE ON DMZ: An example: Putin announced yesterday that he has agreed with Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan to institute a “demilitarized zone” in the north of Syria as a buffer between Syrian government forces and the last bastion of rebel troops. Turkey is ostensibly a U.S. ally, but has increasingly been bending toward Moscow and the influence of Putin.

The DMZ, if it comes to pass, could avert a humanitarian disaster in Syria’s Idlib Province, where opposition forces were facing a final showdown against the troops of President Bashar Assad. The plan is for Russian and Turkish troops to patrol the zone, which would be 115 miles long and 12 miles deep and is to be established by Oct. 15.

The plan faces some obstacles, including a demand that “radical militants” would have to withdraw from the zone, reports the AP.

Good Tuesday morning and welcome to Jamie McIntyre’s Daily on Defense, compiled by Washington Examiner National Security Senior Writer Jamie McIntyre (@jamiejmcintyre), National Security Writer Travis J. Tritten (@travis_tritten) and Senior Editor David Brown (@dave_brown24). Email us here for tips, suggestions, calendar items and anything else. If a friend sent this to you and you’d like to sign up, click here. If signing up doesn’t work, shoot us an email and we’ll add you to our list. And be sure to follow us on Twitter @dailyondefense.

HAPPENING TODAY, ROUND THREE: It was all smiles and warm handshakes today in Pyongyang as South Korean President Moon Jae-in arrived in the North Korean capital for his third go-round with Kim Jong Un over denuclearization. The two leaders could be seen on television coverage waving from an open car as they drove to the site of today’s talks, a ruling Workers’ Party building in Pyongyang. Moon and Kim are scheduled to meet again tomorrow before Moon returns to Seoul Thursday.

The Korea monitoring group 38 North sees a shift in tone coming out of North Korea. “In what appears to be an authoritative-level article in Rodong Sinmun on September 15, Pyongyang has strongly reasserted its commitment to a new relationship with the US and to the process of denuclearization,” analyst Robert Carlin wrote on the group’s website. Carlin noted the article’s warm tone toward Trump, even directly citing Trump’s “thanks” to the North for its positive actions thus far.

“Cast as criticism of ‘U.S. conservative politicians,’ the article can also be read as an attack on opponents within the North. No doubt as it is intended to do, the article gives Kim Jong Un more space to maneuver in dealing with the US and with South Korea,” Carlin wrote.

WHAT KIM WANTS NOW: “Kim is not going to give up nuclear weapons if he believes doing so will compromise North Korea’s security. Progress on denuclearization steps — such as a freeze on fissile material production and a declaration detailing North Korea’s program — depends on U.S. support for a joint political declaration on the end of the Korean War,” said Daryl Kimball, executive director, Arms Control Association.

The Rodong Sinmun article makes the same point, that North Korea wants a formal end to the Korean War as a starting point for moving ahead on denuclearization. “With the danger of war constantly looming, it is not possible for us to unilaterally abandon the nuclear weapons that guarantee our sovereignty, right to exist, and right to develop.”

SYRIA SHOOTS DOWN RUSSIAN PLANE, MOSCOW BLAMES ISRAEL: Russia says one of its Il-20 military planes was accidentally shot down by Syrian air defenses, but the Defense Ministry is blaming the loss of the aircraft and the deaths of 15 people on board on Israel.

Russia says the plane was forced into range of Syrian air defenses by an unannounced Israeli airstrike mission, in which four Israeli F-16 jets were attacking Syrian targets in the province of Latakia.

“Israel did not warn the command of the Russian troops in Syria about the planned operation. We received a notification via a hotline less than a minute before the strike, which did not allow the Russian aircraft to be directed to a safe zone,” Russian Defense Ministry spokesman Maj. Gen. Igor Konashenkov said, according to Sputnik news.

RUSSIA HEARING: David Trachtenberg, deputy undersecretary of defense for policy, testifies to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee on the status of U.S.-Russia arms control efforts at 10 a.m.

SENATE TEES UP DEFENSE BILL: Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell filed cloture on the Pentagon’s 2019 funding bill on Monday evening. The move allows debate to begin today and tees up a final vote on the $674 billion legislation this week. A Senate vote will send it to the House, where a final vote is needed next week when the chamber is back in session so the bill can reach Trump’s desk before the end of the fiscal year on Sept. 30.

SPACE FORCE TO COST $13 BILLION: Trump’s plan to create a new Space Force military service would cost a total of $13 billion over five years, according to a new Air Force estimate. The service said the Pentagon would need to request $3.32 billion next year as part of the president’s proposed budget request to Congress, according to a memo by Wilson described to the Washington Examiner. The Pentagon would also need to spend another $10 billion over the next four years. The Air Force estimate was first reported by Defense One,

In her keynote remarks at the AFA conference yesterday, Wilson said the Air Force is fully committed to ensuring the United States continues to lead in space, and is not waiting for Congress to approve the separate Space Force. “There are actions that the Air Force can take immediately, without further action from Congress,” Wilson said. “We are moving forward with the restructuring of the Space and Missiles Systems Center so that we buy space systems faster and smarter. We are working with the Joint Staff under the guidance of the secretary of defense and the president to establish and support a unified combatant command for space that puts a warfighter’s focus on space operations.”

U.S. ON THE SIDELINES IN SYRIA: The United States does not have to sit back and watch the last of the Syrian opposition be wiped out by Assad, the Brookings Institution’s Michael O’Hanlon and Steven Heydemann wrote in an opinion piece in the Washington Post.

“The Trump administration has rightly threatened to respond if Assad uses chemical weapons in his planned campaign. While commendable, this ignores that conventional weapons — artillery, airstrikes, barrel bombings — account for something like 99 percent of all casualties,” wrote O’Hanlon and Heydemann. The two analysts say the U.S. could invoke international prohibitions against genocide, and the laws of war under Geneva Conventions, to justify a military response.

“Washington should start by vowing to retaliate in the event of any indiscriminate use of violence by Assad against his own people, in a manner of our choosing. This could be done without dramatically escalating U.S. involvement in the war. For example, a helicopter seen to be barrel-bombing an apartment building could later be destroyed by a long-range surface-to-air missile once back at its base,” they suggest, adding that to be effective deterrence should be linked to a diplomatic strategy.

TRUMP TAKES TRANSGENDER CASE TO SCOTUS: Trump is asking the Supreme Court to intervene and halt a federal court order that he turn over thousands of emails and internal documents related to his decision last year to ban transgender people from military service. “That order requires the executive branch, including the president himself, to produce a detailed privilege log of thousands of documents withheld under the presidential communications privilege — and to do so in a manner that reveals information that is itself privileged,” according to the Supreme Court appeal filed by the Justice Department.

Last month, a Washington district court sided with active-duty transgender troops who are suing Trump and Mattis and ordered the Trump administration to prepare to turn over the internal correspondence about the transgender policy. The plaintiffs want to see the documents as part of pretrial discovery and believe it will shed light on Trump’s claim in July 2017 that he consulted with “my Generals and military experts” before issuing a tweet announcing transgender people would be banned from serving in any capacity.

TO THE VICTORS GO THE QUOTES: Navy Personnel Command issued an apology Monday evening after its Twitter account posted a motivational quote from Confederate Navy Capt. Raphael Semmes.

“It has been brought to our attention that today’s Motivation Monday post came across as insensitive. The series consists of leadership quotes throughout our Navy’s history,” the command said. “We used a poor example and we sincerely apologize if we’ve offended anyone.”

The quote itself was innocuous enough. “A military, or a naval man, cannot got far very far astray, who abides by the point of honor.”

THE RUNDOWN

Associated Press: AP looks at the Koreas’ push for formal end to Korean War

Defense News: Air Force finds new KC-46 deficiencies, jeopardizing planned delivery date

Politico: Trump’s Space Force struggling to launch

Defense One: Congress’s Quantum Science Bill May Not Keep the US Military Ahead of China

AFP: Video: Nuclear facilities in Iran

Breaking Defense: Army Insists 1,000-Mile Missiles Won’t Breach INF Treaty

USNI News: Marines at Camp Lejeune Rescue Nearby Civilians Threatened By Flooding

Business Insider: Bad photoshop fools Iranian media into thinking US aircraft carriers are testing UFOs

The Daily Beast: U.S. Paid $1B to Contractor Accused of Bigotry at Iraq Air Base

Calendar

TUESDAY | SEPT. 18

6:45 a.m. 1250 South Hayes St. Special Topic Breakfast with Rear Adm. John Neagley, Program Executive Officer for Navy Unmanned and Small Combatants. navyleague.org

7:45 a.m. The Human Machine Team with David Honey, IC Senior Scientist in the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, and Stacey Dixon, Director of Intelligence Advanced Research Projects Activity. defenseone.com

9 a.m. 201 Waterfront St. AFA’s annual Air, Space & Cyber Conference with Air Force Chief of Staff Gen. David Goldfein. afa.org

10 a.m. Dirksen 419. Full Committee Hearing Status of U.S.-Russia Arms Control Efforts with David Trachtenberg, Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Policy. foreign.senate.gov

10 a.m. 1775 Massachusetts Ave. NW. Mr. X and the Pacific: George F. Kennan and American policy in East Asia. brookings.edu

10 a.m. 1300 Pennsylvania Ave. NW. The Quetta Experience: Attitudes and Values Within the Pakistan Army. wilsoncenter.org

11 a.m. Pentagon Briefing Room. Army Col. Sean Ryan, spokesman, Combined Joint Task Force-Operation Inherent Resolve briefs the media from Baghdad on operations in Iraq and Syria. Live streamed on www.defense.gov/live.

2:30 p.m. Senate Visitor Center 217. Closed Subcommittee Hearing on Interagency Coordination in the Protection of Critical Infrastructure with Kenneth Rapuano, Assistant Secretary of Defense for Homeland Defense and Global Security. Armed-services.senate.gov

4 p.m. Pentagon River Entrance. Defense Secretary Jim Mattis welcomes Philippine Secretary of National Defense Delfin Lorenzama to the Pentagon.

WEDNESDAY | SEPT. 19

6:30 a.m. 2425 Wilson Blvd. Institute of Land Warfare Breakfast Series with Lt. Gen. James Pasquarette, Army Deputy Chief of Staff. ausa.org

8 a.m. 800 17th St. NW. Manufacturing Division Meeting. ndia.org

8:30 a.m. 201 Waterfront St. AFA’s annual Air, Space & Cyber Conference with Deputy Defense Secretary Pat Shanahan. afa.org

9 a.m. 1201 Pennsylvania Ave. NW. Iran’s Missile Proliferation: A Conversation with Special Envoy Brian Hook. hudson.org

12:30 p.m. 1201 Pennsylvania Ave. NW. Iraq: Escalating Domestic and Regional Tensions. hudson.org

3:30 p.m. 1616 Rhode Island Ave. NW. Book Launch: A Covert Action. csis.org

THURSDAY | SEPT. 20

7:30 a.m. 800 17th St. NW. Manufacturing Division Meeting. ndia.org

8 a.m. 2401 M St. NW. Defense Writers Group Breakfast with Kelly McKeague, Director of the Defense POW/MIA Accounting Agency.

9 a.m. 2301 Constitution Ave. RESOLVE Network 2018 Global Forum: Innovative Approaches to Understanding Violent Extremism. usip.org

11 a.m. 1000 Massachusetts Ave. NW. The Liberal International Order: Past, Present, and Future. cato.org

3:30 p.m. 1616 Rhode Island Ave. NW. Press Briefing: Analysis of the FY 2019 Defense Budget. csis.org

6 p.m. 529 23rd St. South. SO/LIC Division Social. ndia.org

FRIDAY | SEPT. 21

8 a.m. 300 First St. SE. The Post-NPR Nuclear Weapons Stockpile with Peter Fanta, Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Nuclear Matters. mitchellaerospacepower.org

12 noon. 1201 Pennsylvania Ave. NW. U.S.-Japan Cooperation in Strategic Island Defense with Retired Gen. James Conway, Former Marine Corps Commandant. hudson.org

MONDAY | SEPT. 24

8 a.m. 3701 Post Office Rd. The Industrial Committee on Test and Evaluation. ndia.org

TUESDAY | SEPT. 25

8 a.m. 300 1st St. SE. Missile Defense Perspectives with Retired Lt. Gen. Richard Formica, Vice President of Defense Accounts at Calibre, and Retired Brig. Gen. Kenneth Todorov, Vice President of Missile Defense Solutions at Northrop Grumman. mitchellaerospacepower.org

9:30 a.m. Dirksen G-50. Nomination Hearing for Gen. Robert Abrams to be Commander, United Nations Command, Combined Forces Command, and U.S. Forces Korea; and Vice Adm. Craig Faller, to be Commander of U.S. Southern Command. armed-services.senate.gov

QUOTE OF THE DAY
“Our dominance as a global power is not a birthright. It is a choice, made by a nation that is a force for good in the world. It is a choice, made by a nation that is not naive about the existence of evil. And new threats are emerging to which our generation must respond.”
Air Force Secretary Heather Wilson, speaking at the Air Force Association’s Air, Space & Cyber Conference yesterday.

Related Content