Chronicling Dixie in the Depression

Published



In 1954, when I was a sophomore at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, I paid tribute in an editorial for the Daily Tar Heel to a distinguished predecessor at that illustrious student paper, William T. Polk, who had died unexpectedly. Jonathan W. Daniels, the journalist and editor who had been Polk’s friend and contemporary, mailed a note commenting on my piece and inviting me to visit him at his newspaper office in Raleigh. I soon did so—beginning a friendship that continued until his death in 1981. So, having known Daniels rather well as one of my journalistic elders, I am pleasantly surprised by the perceptiveness with which Jennifer Ritterhouse writes of his era and outlook. Her subject is A Southerner Discovers the South, a Daniels bestseller of 1938, one of a cluster of remarkable contemporaneous works—W. J. Cash’s The Mind of the South; C. Vann Woodward’s biography of the chameleon Georgia journalist-politician Tom Watson; and William Alexander Percy’s elegiac Lanterns on the Levee—that announced the South’s awakening from dogmatic slumbers.

The personalities and problems Daniels chronicled following a tour of 10 ex-Confederate states have faded from public consciousness. But that hardly matters, since their stories foreshadowed enduring perplexities. As a liberal journalist, Daniels’s preeminent concern was the case of the “Scottsboro Boys,” nine young black men who hopped a freight train in 1931 and were arrested in Alabama after two mendacious prostitutes accused them of rape. The case epitomized Jim Crow—including corrupt juries that ignored, among other salient facts, one accuser’s repudiation of her testimony. Not even a U.S. Supreme Court decision quashing the original verdict sufficed to end the boys’ decade-long ordeal. The case attracted national and international attention. It had few heroes, save for a bold Alabama judge who set aside one of several jury verdicts, but it had racist villains galore. Daniels, to his credit, editorialized vigorously against these injustices, both in his book and in the Raleigh News and Observer, the newspaper his family owned.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.