You should take the time to read Hugh Hewitt’s interview with General David Petraeus, who gives an excellent assessment of where Operation Phantom Thunder stands right now. He covers both the successes and the challenges. Some highlights:
Many of our readers note the progress of Operation Phantom Thunder and are optimistic that Petraeus will recommend continued commitment to supporting the government and people of Iraq in their efforts at stabilizing the security situation there. It may therefore be worth pointing out that Petraeus isn’t telegraphing such a recommendation. He seems to be stating pretty clearly that there are some real successes with ‘the surge’ and, at least on the military side, it’s accomplishing what it ought to. But that’s not the same as recommending that the mission continue. Rather, such a determination is probably a necessary but not sufficient condition to recommend continued commitment. Petraeus says that when he reports in September, he will present a ‘comprehensive and forthright assessment’ of the progress that has been achieved, and where we’ve fallen short. He’s said elsewhere that he will lay out potential options and consequences. Since political progress is necessary as well, this interview doesn’t give us too much to go on with regard to any recommendations he may make. On a minor point, it’s worth noting that this interview does not seem consistent with what Armed Services Committee Member Jack Reed said Petraeus told him. Reed said that he was surprised when Petraeus volunteered that he would probably be able to make a recommendation on the surge in August, and that he was prepared for a ‘change of direction.’ To put it mildly, one of these two accounts has to be wrong.
