Upset Brewing in ‘Safe’ Democratic Seat?

Indiana’s 7th Congressional district will play host to a special election on March 11, as a result of the passing of Representative Julia Carson on December 15. Carson never ran up huge margins in her Congressional seat; she won her last three races with about 54% of the vote. The district’s Partisan Vote Index is Democrat +9, meaning that the average Democrat defeats the average Republican by 9 points. All-in-all, it’s a safe Democratic seat. In special elections however, odd things can sometimes happen. And while it’s a longshot, this could be one time with the underdog pulls off a surprise. The Republican candidate is Jon Elrod, who was elected to the Indiana statehouse in a major upset in 2006. He defeated a 10-year Democratic incumbent by just 8 votes. His first race was in 2004, when he won as a big underdog in a race for the Center Township Board. In addition to his narrow statehouse win, Indianapolis was also home to an extraordinary upset in the 2006 Mayoral race, where voter anger over crime and taxes led to the victory of political newcomer Greg Ballard, in a race considered by some to be the biggest upset in Indiana history. (Although sensible people recognize that this is.)

Elrod is well-known for his grass-roots politicking. He attributes his wins so far to knocking on thousands of doors. And since his Democratic opponent is a product of the local machine, he’s got a chance. A Democratic partisan recently predicted his win in a post at the popular liberal blog MyDD:

The Party did not take the time to listen to its voters. Andre Carson is a blank slate. At the lone candidate forum, he managed to say there may need to be residual troops left in Iraq, that being gay is a choice, and that he doesn’t believe in Universal Health Care. The Republicans have nominated a pro-choice, gay-friendly, 30-year-old moderate as their candidate. He is smart, likeable, and was able to defeat State Representative Ed Mahern, a Democratic leader and architect of Indiana’s 2001/2002 redistricting plan. That was in a solidly Democratic district in a Democratic wave year, 2006. Jon Elrod is a Republican that moderate and anti-nepotism Democrats will vote for over Mr. Carson, who has served just 4 months on the City County Council. In 2007, our Democratic mayor and several Democratic city councilors lost their quest for reelection and city government flipped to the Republican Party. This was party due to the tax issue, but also because of increasing corruption and incompetence in the party leadership. By nominating Andre Carson, the insiders showed they didn’t learn their lesson from last November.

This is a race to keep your eye on. The Democrats are worried enough about this unfavorable candidate matchup that the DCCC is committing money to Carson’s race. They know that a Republican win here would be an extraordinary black eye for the party, and would demonstrate that Republican congressional hopes are not as weak as some might think. You can see a recent address by Elrod here.

Related Content