Third and Final Navy SEAL Acquitted of Terrorist-Punching Charges

A military jury in Norfolk, Va. acquitted the third and final Navy SEAL court martialed in connection with the alleged assault of an Iraqi suspected in the 2004 murders of four U.S. contractors in Fallujah.

“I’m really happy right now,” Matthew McCabe, the Navy SEAL, told Fox News shortly after hearing the outcome of the court martial. “It’s an amazing feeling. I’m on cloud nine right now.”
McCabe, a special operations petty officer second class, called the proceedings “troubling at times,” adding “having your career on the line is not an easy thing to handle.”

Two other SEALS, Julio Huertas and Jonathan Keefe, were found not guilty in the incident in separate trials in Baghdad. The defense’s argument centered on testimony from an oral surgeon who said Ahmed Hashim Abed’s injury could have been self-inflicted. Al Qaeda operatives are known to be trained to claim abuse by American captors.

The prosecution battled questions about the credibility of its key witness, who did not initially report an incident, but later said he saw McCabe punch Abed. The prosecution also had a line of questioning backfire when its witness corroborated the defense’s argument.

Thursday afternoon, prosecutors suffered an apparent setback when a witness they called supported the defense position on disputed statements submitted in writing by two Navy SEALs in Iraq shortly after the alleged assault. The prosecution claimed the two SEALs, Jonathan Keefe and Matthew McCabe, colluded to get their stories straight, because their statements appeared to be identical. But the witness whose testimony backfired for the prosecution acknowledged the statements of two SEALs on the same mission often coincide.

Support Our SEALS held rallies across the nation in support of McCabe on the day of his trial.

Video of McCabe talking with Fox & Friends this morning is here.

Related Content