Freeman Wanted Out of Afghanistan Now?

Ted Bromund writes at Contentions:

…a friend pointed out an interesting item in the February 26, 2009, New York Review of Books: a petition calling on the U.S. to withdraw immediately and totally from Afghanistan. One signatory, predictably, was Norman Finkelstein. Another, equally predictably, was Chas Freeman. That petition was published weeks before Freeman’s name was put forward as the arbiter of U.S. intelligence assessments.

I’m trying to track down a hard-copy of the petition, and will post as soon as I do, but there is no reason to doubt what Bromund says. The man who the Obama administration appointed to oversee the creation of national intelligence estimates was, just a few months ago, signing petitions for the immediate withdrawal of U.S. troops from Afghanistan. This is the man who James Fallows would praise for his “contrarianism,” which included extremely contrarian views on Israel, China, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, and now Afghanistan. Was Dennis Blair aware that the man he was bringing on to head the NIC had been singing public petitions that would directly contradict the policies of the Obama administration? Imagine if Freeman hadn’t withdrawn from consideration (or been tossed overboard depending on who you believe), the IG reports would still be in the offing, members of Congress would still be protesting the choice, and now we’d have the new head of Obama’s National Intelligence Council explaining how his name got onto a petition calling for the complete withdrawal of U.S. forces from Afghanistan — and how those views would never interfere with his assessment of the war there and the prospect for an American victory (which he would surely be working diligently to secure). Imagine that. Update: I now have a copy of the petition, titled “Not This Time.” It reads:

Dear President Obama, We congratulate you and wish you the very best of fortune in your great undertainking. As writers, we admire your eloquence and your engagement with ideas. But we are worried because a new beginning will not be possible as long as we continue to spill the blood of the men, women, and children of Afghanistan. The Taliban is not a direct military threat to the United States nor are the people of Afghanistan. There is no victory for those who attempt to occupy Afghanistan, as the Soviets and the British discovered. There will be no progress at home while such an all-consuming war is ebing waged. If we stay, the situation will get worse, not better, and the toll in American lives and American prestige , as well as the damage to our standing in the Middle East and to the American budget will be staggering and tragic. We urge you to negotiate with the Taliban, withdraw all troops from Afghanistan, and begin the moral and physical rebuilding of Afghanistan, as well as that of the United States.

That is the full text. “The Taliban is not a direct military threat to the United States.” That is the view of the man whom Dennis Blair would have installed as the head of the National Intelligence Council.

Related Content