Clinton to Israel: Peace or Else

Secretary of State Clinton yesterday issued a warning to Israel: negotiate “peace” with the “Palestinians” or risk losing the support of the Arab world in your efforts to counter the Iranian threat. At the same time, she suggested the Obama administration’s diplomatic outreach to Tehran was the proper antidote to a “failed Bush administration policy”:

“We tried the policy of total isolation for eight years,” she said in a rising voice, “and it did not deter Iran one bit. The nuclear program has continued unabated. They weren’t supporting Hamas before. They are supporting Hamas now.”

Several problems arise: First, Bush-Rice/Olmert-Livni efforts (to name only the most recent) notwithstanding, there is no peace for Israel with people who to this day do not recognize her right to exist. Second, Arab states have as much to fear from Tehran’s nuclear and hegemonic ambitions as does Israel, and this will be so whether the-peace-negotiations-that-never-end continue to be forced upon the Israelis or not. Third, if she and the rest of the Obami believe there is consensus in the Arab world on any subject whatsoever, they have some lessons still to learn. “The problem of the Arab world is not that its leaders do not meet,” editorialized Tareq al-Homayed in London’s Al-Sharq Al-Awsat after the recent Arab summit in Doha,

The problem is [the way in which] they meet. This is clear from all the summits that have taken place until now, for what is agreed upon is never implemented, and the suggestions always repeat themselves. . . . In light of what we have heretofore seen, I think that the Arab summits should [always] be held at the Cairo headquarters, each of them chaired by a different Arab country, on a rotating basis. This, in order to avoid ineffective competition and unwanted invitations. . . . The trustworthy and faithful [leaders] find themselves facing leaders that say [things] but do not act on them, and who lead our region from one disaster to the next.

And, finally, while our secretary of state is studying up, here’s something else she might usefully learn: contrary to her assertion, the Iranians have been supporting Hamas since at least the beginning of the Second Intifada in 2000. You remember that, don’t you Mrs. C.?

Related Content