Graham and Lieberman React to Gitmo Ruling

Lindsey Graham says he’ll seek measures to “blunt the effect” of the Supreme Court’s “dangerous an irresponsible” decision that gives enemy combatants access to U.S. civilian courts:

The Court’s decision is bad on many levels and I will continue to review the decision and determine its sweeping effect on our military. I will also explore the possibility, if necessary, of a constitutional amendment to blunt the effect of this decision when it comes to protecting our men and women in the military and our nation as a whole. The Court has conferred upon civilian judges the right to make military decisions. These judges have virtually no training in military matters yet civilian judges, in some of the most liberal district courts in the country, will have an opportunity to determine who is a threat to the United States . Furthermore, the habeas trials will put great burdens on our military forces. Enemy combatants potentially may be able to sue American troops for money damages and federal judges will now be in charge of the day-to-day military prisons and the interrogation of prisoners. This will empower activist lawyers and interest groups to intervene in basic military matters for the first time in history. … I agree with Chief Justice John Roberts who noted the legal procedures available to detainees today are unprecedented and more than sufficient. I only wish one more member of the Court would have listened to his wise counsel. Instead, they took what I consider to be completely dangerous and irresponsible actions during a time of war.

Also, Sen. Lieberman has some strong words in response to today’s decision:

The Supreme Court’s decision fails, in a dramatic way, to appreciate that we are at war and that our enemies are relentless in their pursuit of our destruction. Let us not forget that at least 30 prisoners that have been released have already returned to the battlefield.

Update: Jon Kyl, the junior senator from Arizona, poses a good question: “I ask those who laud today’s decision as a victory whether they would want Osama bin Laden, if captured, to be processed by our civilian judicial system?”

Related Content