Michael Novak’s ideal of “democratic capitalism” sounds like it has two elements, but it really has three. In The Spirit of Democratic Capitalism (1982), Novak defined the American system as a triple alliance of free markets, a democratic polity, and a classically liberal system of values. In Novak’s American and Catholic application of Max Weber’s German and Protestant theories, the spirit of a culture shapes the matter of its governance and the materials of its capitalism.
Two’s company; three’s a crowd. At the end of the Cold War, democratic capitalism inherited the earth. The years until the Great Recession were a global victory tour. Those of us who enjoyed its progress must now admit that the Western-sponsored market system and Western politicians alike frequently treated values, the ethical foundation of society, as a silent partner. In the United States and Europe, politicians like Bill Clinton and Tony Blair even persuaded centrist voters to let them push values out of bed entirely, the better to enjoy their intimacy with the free market. But across the West, that silent partner has come to life in various “shock” election results in recent years.