David Gergen from a March 14 broadcast on CNN:
Well, because there’s a long tradition, Anderson. And among black leaders to have a different view of American history, going all the way back to Frederick Douglass, who was one of the greatest American heroes of the 19th century, you know, who — who gained his freedom from slavery in a great order. He was invited the a July 4th celebration to give a July 4th speech in 1852, and he showed up and said, “You know, you whites see July 4 very differently from what I see it. This is not a day of celebration for us.” And I have found that in my classroom with black students frequently. When they speak their minds and when they speak their hearts, they have a very different view. I’ve had a young woman tell me, “July 4, we still can’t celebrate it in my family, because of what’s happened to us.” And I think that we as whites have to be understanding and empathic toward that and try to understand that, that people who are African-Americans legitimately have a different perspective on what American history has meant and take that into account as we hear this. And it’s not a lack of patriotism. It is a different form of patriotism. Actually, Reverend Wright may love this country more than any of us but feel we’ve fallen short of what we preach and believe.
Exit question: Is it wrong to enjoy David Gergen’s monumental moronitudousnes on a kitsch level? Alternate exit question: Is it possible to distinguish between the America of 1852 and the America of today?

