Since the revolution in national politics precipitated by the election of Donald Trump, many have reflected on conservatism’s record and legacy. Because Trump represents a new kind of populist, anti-establishment conservatism, there has been much lamentation over Reagan-style conservatism’s perceived decline.

This lamentation is appropriate; something important seems to have passed away, not least of which is civility and compassion in public discourse. But however much we may regret this, we must acknowledge an uncomfortable truth: Conservatism has systematically failed to conserve anything.