Protests targeting “Zionists” in America quickly crossed partisan lines. Antifa-aligned and “social justice” networks on the Left turned campuses and cities into sites of disruption and eliminationist rhetoric.
Right-wing groups such as Patriot Front ran parallel actions with banners like “No Zionists in Government,” advancing antisemitic appeals inside white-nationalist programs. Both represent collectivist extremism. Fascism arose historically from socialist premises by repurposing state power, mobilizing identity, and rejecting individualism. The link is structural: Movements that subordinate individuals and the constitutional order to group grievance or tribal supremacy reliably produce authoritarian outcomes, whether in progressive or nationalist form.
Recommended Stories
Recent data confirms the scale. FBI statistics recorded 1,938 anti-Jewish hate crimes in 2024 — the highest annual figure — making up 69% of religion-based incidents despite Jews comprising roughly 2% of the population. Much of the post-October 2023 surge aligned with left-wing protest activity, while right-wing propaganda persisted in the background. Pew Research Center data show 8 in 10 Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents now view Israel unfavorably, marking a sharp ideological realignment inside the party.
This shift directly alters America’s foreign policy. Vice President JD Vance’s untraditional right-wing impulses toward strategic retrenchment risk dismantling the pro-Western orientation built over decades, acting as a self-imposed perestroika that weakens deterrence without delivering peace. On the Left, the Democratic Party’s socialist current is positioned to accelerate immigration from Muslim-majority, Arab, and South Asian regions, as Europe experienced. Legal permanent residency grants to nationals of Muslim-majority countries rose 81% from fiscal 2000 to 2023, more than doubling the foreign-born population from those nations. California, Texas, Florida, and New York absorb the largest shares and concentrate both demographic change and accompanying policy experiments.
Continued trajectories make constitutional adjustments broadening high-office eligibility more likely, opening paths for socialist officials who have tested or benefited from debates over long-standing requirements. Demographically transformed states, including traditional GOP strongholds such as Florida and Texas, would likely shift further left, joining California and New York in dominating national direction. The United States would then replicate Europe’s pattern with the usual 30-year lag: high immigration without robust integration, expanded welfare commitments, identity-based politics, and reduced external posture. America has already ceased to be what it was.
Neither the Right nor the Left offers a coherent alternative. Both contain strong isolationist strains, treating traditional alliances as optional or burdensome. They have normalized accommodating adversaries by adopting elements of their framing — an approach tracing to the Obama-era Iran engagement that cooled relations with Israel and historical key allies. The result is a posture resentful toward capable allies such as Jerusalem while lacking the will to defend them decisively, repeating patterns of moral clarity in the absence of sustained commitment.
Within a few years, compounding pressures will likely produce a major external crisis on the scale of 9/11. By then, bipartisan consensus against decisive military engagement abroad will have hardened. The domestic landscape will feature a growing segment that wants to be “respected without fighting,” alongside those who recognize that respect rests on demonstrated capacity and will. Their collision risks a national shock whose scale and consequences are hard to bound. Civil conflict is not the most probable but cannot be dismissed.
PRESIDENT MAMDANI? HERE’S THE NEXT DEMOCRATIC POWER GRAB
The U.S., therefore, operates as an empire in voluntary decline, following Britain’s precedent 70 years ago. America increasingly resembles Europe in its demographic trajectory, institutional capture by collectivist factions, and the erosion of martial and civic resolve.
Republics decay when ideological extremes capture public life, when America admits populations with incompatible values yet refuses to demand integration, and when it loses the will to defend allies. That is not fate. It is national self-destruction happening in plain sight.
Jose Lev Alvarez is an American–Israeli scholar specializing in international security policy. A multilingual veteran of the IDF special forces and the U.S. Army, he holds three master’s degrees and is completing a Ph.D. in Intelligence and Global Security in the Washington, D.C., area.
