CNN’s Don Lemon hosted a town hall Monday evening with 2020 candidate Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn. While I initially thought she lacked the charisma needed in today’s 24/7 social media environment to even be considered a strong Democratic candidate, I was surprised at how well she did at the town hall. I still wouldn’t assign “charismatic” to her as a descriptive term, but she billed herself as a “pragmatic progressive” and indeed, that’s how she came across. In a refreshing twist, she provided answers that were far more specific than most Democrat politicians, while also evading the “hope and change” optimism that most Democrats tend to adopt. From what I saw on social media, the town hall was a hit with moderate Democrats, her target audience.
Whether or not you agree with her on every issue, Senator Amy Klobuchar comes across as a knowledgeable, thoughtful, impressive candidate in this #KlobucharTownHall. If nothing else, these town halls demonstrate the stark contrast between Trump and the Democrats. https://t.co/RudPVyJZ6H
— Keith Boykin (@keithboykin) February 19, 2019
Here are the main takeaways from Klobuchar’s town hall.
She hit back at Trump, but wasn’t too caustic.
Where Hillary Clinton and Sen. Kamala Harris, D-Calif., tended to be caustic and biting when they referred to President Trump, Klobuchar pushed back on his style and his governing choices without sounding like the Wicked Witch of the West. After one question about Trump, Klobuchar said, “I think the first thing is to stop governing by tweet … You have to have someone that you have faith in, that respects the institution.” This garnered applause and even as a conservative, I have to say I agreed. When asked about Trump securing a border wall via national emergency, she responded short and to the point: “I think it’s unconstitutional.” For many people, brevity from a politician is refreshing. While most expect a Democrat to disagree with a Republican president, she did it in a way that elevated the debate.
She approached addiction in a really human way.
During Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s hearing, alcohol use was a main point of contention between Republicans and Democrats on the Senate Judiciary Committee. Klobuchar pointed out her father was alcoholic and thus the issue was important to her. When asked about this during the town hall, she responded with sincerity and in a personal way.
“How do you pay for [addiction recovery programs]? Well, I’ve got a good start. And that is, why don’t we pay for it by getting money from the very drug companies that got people addicted in the first place.” — Sen. Amy Klobuchar #KlobucharTownHall
— Amy Klobuchar (@amyklobuchar) February 19, 2019
Sen. Amy Klobuchar emotionally describes how her relationship with her father, a prominent journalist who dealt with alcoholism for much of his life, shaped her views on fighting addiction and helping people find redemption. #KlobucharTownHall https://t.co/h4vjNvIlDh pic.twitter.com/VW62dg52wH
— CNN (@CNN) February 19, 2019
Klobuchar articulated that even despite his alcoholism, her relationship with her father remains strong to this day. This helped inform how she was as a prosecutor, always pushing for reform and for treatment in order to help people actually change and heal from addiction. She said, “In [my father’s] own words he was ‘pursued by grace.’” The slightly religious tone of grace and redemption as it relates to besetting issues like addiction is one many people on the Left and Right can relate to, and could really endear her to voters.
Despite a few pleasant surprises, there was of course quite a bit of progressive politics at play, the likes of which might appeal to centrist voters because she still broke with liberals in a couple key areas.
She doesn’t think college should be free — at least not completely
When asked about college, Klobuchar said she didn’t think all public colleges should be paid for by the government, just two-year community colleges. Four-year public colleges and universities should not be “free.” This is a huge point for those in the middle who advocate for personal responsibility while feeling guilty that young people are graduating college with lots of debt.
Klobuchar explains why she doesn’t support free college for all https://t.co/ZDHc7srMmg #KlobucharTownHall pic.twitter.com/QKsoqjSv26
— CNN Politics (@CNNPolitics) February 19, 2019
Klobuchar still backs universal healthcare
When one woman asked why we couldn’t have so-called “Medicare for all,” Klobuchar responded that she believed America should adopt a universal healthcare system, but it might not necessarily look like Medicare for everybody. I think she was trying to avoid adopting what conservatives view as a radical, socialist idea, while at the same time, basically supporting it.
Democratic Sen. Amy Klobuchar on if the US can have “Medicare-for-all”: “It could be a possibility in the future. I’m just looking at something that will work now.” #KlobucharTownHall https://t.co/wMhsO2I0j3 pic.twitter.com/9sA9lD82zO
— CNN (@CNN) February 19, 2019
Klobuchar is still gung ho on climate change
While Klobuchar said the Green New Deal was “important to have but there need to be compromises,” and she also backed the Paris climate agreement 100 percent.
“On my first day as President, I will sign us back into the International Climate Agreement.” — Sen. Amy Klobuchar #KlobucharTownHall
— Amy Klobuchar (@amyklobuchar) February 19, 2019
She dodged the question about her staff
BuzzFeed News recently reported on several members of Klobuchar’s staff, saying she had a temper and often yelled or even threw objects at them in a huff.
When asked about her notorious temper, she basically said she has high standards for herself, and thus her staff, and America — and totally dodged the question. Whether this will come back to bite her depends on how much the alleged claims are true and if so, what her staff or former staff do about it, if anything.
“Am I a tough boss sometimes? Yes. Have I pushed people too hard? Yes,” Sen. Amy Klobuchar says about her leadership style. “But I have kept expectations for myself that are very high. I’ve asked my staff to meet those same expectations.” #KlobucharTownHall pic.twitter.com/zBQ0rbvcq7
— CNN (@CNN) February 19, 2019
She still advocates “common-sense gun safety legislation”
Not surprisingly, Klobuchar called for more gun control. She said she would ban assault rifles and often thinks of it as whether or not a ban on that would hurt family members in Minnesota who like to hunt. Her ability to place practical boundaries on it might appeal to voters who too think that seems like common sense.
“We should join the majority of Americans and actually many gun owners in having the courage to pass common sense gun safety legislation.” – Sen. Amy Klobuchar addresses the issue of gun violence in America. #KlobucharTownHall https://t.co/h4vjNvIlDh pic.twitter.com/v7mvmgh1vB
— CNN (@CNN) February 19, 2019
Nicole Russell (@russell_nm) is a contributor to the Washington Examiner’s Beltway Confidential blog. She is a journalist who previously worked in Republican politics in Minnesota.