Department of Justice Inspector General Michael Horowitz’s report strongly indicates that either former Attorney General Loretta Lynch or former President Bill Clinton is lying about how Clinton came to board Lynch’s plane at Sky Harbor International Airport in Phoenix in June 2016. That meeting took place as the FBI was conducting its investigation into Hillary Clinton’s possible mishandling of classified material. When it became public, the meeting thus raised concerns that Lynch was being pressured by or colluding with the former president to prevent Hillary Clinton from being prosecuted.

Yet while Horowitz’s report does not shed light on whether the Hillary Clinton email investigation came up in the meeting between Lynch and Clinton’s husband (both parties deny that it was raised), the report does suggest that Bill Clinton or Lynch is lying. Because the two stories do not add up.