In a unanimous decision in the recent case Timbs v. Indiana, the Supreme Court took a major step toward ending legalized theft. In a sensible move that prohibits state and local governments from imposing excessive fines, the court took a step toward protecting property rights. This ruling is uniquely important because it also restricts state and local governments from excessive government property seizure using civil asset forfeiture, a practice which allows law enforcement to take an individual’s property if it’s at all related to a suspected crime. Now, if the court determines the property value is too high, state and local governments can’t take the property through forfeiture.
Yet, even after the Timbs v. Indiana ruling, the problem of civil asset forfeiture needs fixing. This process is still highly subject to abuse, and should be restricted to cases with a successful conviction, if not completely abolished.