Stop politicizing tragedies: The White House edition

The White House has released a video politicizing the death of Mollie Tibbetts, a 20-year-old woman whom authorities believe was murdered by an illegal immigrant in Iowa.

It is the crassest exploitation of a violent tragedy since former President Barack Obama surrounded himself with children one month after the Sandy Hook massacre to announce his new gun control initiatives.

“For 34 days, investigators searched for 20-year-old Mollie Tibbetts. Yesterday, an illegal alien, now charged with first-degree murder, led police to the cornfield where her body was found,” the White House tweeted Wednesday. “The Tibbetts family has been permanently separated. They are not alone.”


The tweet comes with a video, titled “permanently separated,” featuring several real-life victims who have lost family members to violence committed by illegal immigrants. The victims’ stories are tragic. The video is effective.

The video’s release this week is also a transparent act of grotesque political opportunism.

I’ve said this before, and I’ll say it again here: Please stop politicizing tragedies. In January 2017, following a deadly shooting in Fort Lauderdale, Fla., I wrote this in response to the anti-gun zealots who use every shooting event to further their cause:

In the wake of mass casualty events involving firearms or other items (trucks and knives comes to mind), there’s room to question motives and draw trend lines. There’s even room to attribute blame.
But can we at least wait until after the bodies have been collected before we do any of those things?
Well-meaning people can help by offering aid and comfort to the survivors and to the family and friends of the victims. Well-meaning people can help by donating blood or other materials. They can help by contacting the authorities to see if there’s a need for additional assistance, like transportation for the survivors.
What doesn’t help, however, is rushing immediately after these attacks to pin the blame on certain groups or persons. It’s crass, and it stinks of opportunism, especially when the facts are unclear.
In the name of common decency, and out of respect for those affected by the violence, wait until the deceased are at least in the morgue before you hop on your hobby horse.


Everything I wrote in 2017 applies here with the news that law enforcement officers have charged a reported illegal immigrant in Tibbetts’ death. Just switch out the words “firearms” and replace it with “immigrants,” and you get the same thing.

In the wake of this woman’s murder, don’t rush to pin the blame on certain groups or persons, especially when it’s not clear whether the man charged in her killing is even an illegal immigrant. And especially don’t politicize tragedy when the family members themselves are begging you not to.

You’d think the White House of all places would take a softer approach to the Tibbetts news, especially considering it was press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders who said in 2017 that presidents shouldn’t use tragedies to champion policy.

Gun control, immigration reform – it doesn’t matter. Stop using dead people for political gain, especially if their loved ones haven’t even had a chance to put them in the ground.

Related Content