Debbie messes with Texas

Published August 14, 2011 4:00am ET



On Face the Nation, Norah O’Donnell asked DNC Chairwoman Debbie Wasserman Schultz (a congresswoman from Florida) about her recent claim that the nation’s economic situation has gotten better since President Obama took office. After all, O’Donnell pointed out, unemployment is up about 25 percent since January 2009, and 13.5 million more people are on food stamps since then.

Predictably, Wasserman Schultz replied that it’s all Bush’s fault:

“President Obama inherited a huge problem — the worst recession that we’ve had since the Great Depression, created by the failed policies of the previous Republican administration, where we went from a record surplus to a record deficit. And so working our way out of that problem is extremely challenging.

For the record, if President Obama wins a second term, I fully expect to hear this line until January 2017. Wasserman Schultz went on to criticize Texas Gov. Rick Perry, R, for claiming credit for his own state’s creation of half the jobs America has created since Obama became president:

“It’s extremely difficult for him to deserve credit for that job creation when you have rising gas prices that created oil jobs that he had nothing to do with; when you have military spending as a result of two wars that created military jobs that he had nothing to do with; when you have the Recovery Act championed by President Obama that created jobs in Texas that he had nothing to do with, so it is way overblown to suggest that job creation in Texas is squarely on the shoulders of his policies.”

First of all, think about this for a second: Her argument strikes not only at Perry’s claim to job creation, but Obama’s as well. After all, she’s downplaying half the jobs created on Obama’s watch, isn’t she?

Second, look at the interesting implied line of argument here: Perry, whose state verifiably gained jobs, has no business claiming credit. President Obama, who has presided over huge job losses (which may or may not have anything to do with his policies), is perfectly within his rights to claim credit for “saving” millions of jobs, even if there is no way of verifying the claim.

I sense some real weakness in the Democratic message shop right now. The underlying defense of President Obama (Gallup approval rating: 39 percent) is looking a bit thin at the moment. The Democrats are going to have to come up with something a lot better than that.