Will Wilkinson and Ramesh Ponnuru have both responded to recent articles Tim Carney have written trying to flesh out what the specifics of a libertarian populist agenda might look like. You can read Carney’s response to both critics here.

Both Wilkinson and Ponnuru have nothing but kind words for the actual policies identified by Tim and me, but, as Ponnuru writes and Wilksinson quotes him, “Taken together, though, they do not seem to amount to a winning political platform.”