WSJ/NBC Poll: Only 28% support Occupy movement

The Wall Street Journal reports that:

More than three-quarters of Americans say the country’s economic structure is out of balance and “favors a very small proportion of the rich over the rest of the country,” taking up the calls of Occupy Wall Street protesters to reduce the power of major banks and end tax breaks for the affluent and for corporations, a new Wall Street Journal/NBC News poll shows.

But the actual question does not mention Occupy Wall Street. Instead we ge these two questions:

Q6 Now I’m going to read you the names of several public figures, and groups and I’d like you to rate your feelings toward each one as very positive, somewhat positive, neutral, somewhat negative, or very negative. If you don’t know the name, please just say so.
The Occupy Wall Street Movement: 16% very positive, 16% somewhat positive, 20% neutral, 12% somewhat negative, 23% very negative, 13% don’t know name
Q22 Do you consider yourself a supporter of the Occupy Wall Street Movement?
28% Yes, 63% No, 2% Depends, 7% Not sure

How can The Journal lead with a statement that 75% of Americans agree with the Occupy movement, but then fail to include the net negatives on the movement in their write up?

Here is the question The Journal bases their lead on:

Q30 Now, I’m going to read you two short descriptions of what some people are thinking these days when it comes to government and the economy. Please tell me if you strongly agree, mildly agree, feel neutral about, mildly disagree, or strongly disagree with each set of ideas. (ROTATE)

The current economic structure of the country is out of balance and favors a very small proportion of the rich over the rest of the country. America needs to reduce the power of major banks and corporations and demand greater accountability and transparency. The government should not provide financial aid to corporations and should not provide tax breaks to the rich.
The national debt must be cut significantly by reducing spending and the size of government, including eliminating some federal agencies and programs. Regulations on business by the federal government should be reduced and instead, the private sector and individuals should have greater control. The government should not raise taxes on anyone.

But how can The Journal assign the first view to the Occupy movement? The first sentence can be assigned to them maybe. But the second is a total projection by the pollsters. The Occupy movement quite famously has not come up with policy proposals. More importantly, the vast majority of Tea Party members would agree with the second two sentences: “America needs to reduce the power of major banks and corporations and demand greater accountability and transparency. The government should not provide financial aid to corporations and should not provide tax breaks to the rich.”

Juxtaposing the first and second statements is a completely bogus way to compare the views of the Occupy and Tea Party movements.

 

Related Content