GOP ex-Senator knocks GOP for Ex-Im subsidies

John Sununu, Republican former senator from New Hampshire, knocked his party-mates today for supporting subsidies for major manufacturers. The matter at hand: reauthorization and expansion of the Export-Import Bank, a government agency that uses loans and loan guarantees to subsidize U.S. exports.

Sununu makes this distinction in his Boston Globe op-ed:

[T]oo many members of Congress think that being pro-business means being pro-subsidy…. [P]rograms that bestow unique benefits to favored companies or industries are simply giving away money.  

I typically say that “pro-market” is not the same as “pro-business,” but we’re making the same point. Sununu points out that Ex-Im’s clientele (mostly Boeing) aren’t startups who can’t get private financing, and that government steering the flow of capital is less efficient than the market steering the flow of capital. But he also makes the same political point I made in a recent column. Sununu writes:

For Republicans, it’s also self-defeating politics. It will be far tougher to criticize President Obama’s government-knows-best attitude if Republicans pander to their own set of interests using the same playbook.

It’s really a great op-ed that makes many excellent points. Sununu sees Richard Lugar’s defeat in Indiana as evidence that the GOP base is still worked up about subsidies, even if the party’s politicians have moved past that hangup.

I also really like this prudential warning, about how picking winners and losers always plays into the Left’s hands in the long run:

Inevitably, special treatment for the few becomes subject to exploitation, expansion, and mission creep — and can come back to haunt you. In 2004 a Republican Congress created a credit for manufacturers that lowers their marginal tax rate from 35 to 32 percent. Today, liberals call that program a “loophole” for oil and gas companies. It was a bad idea to start with, but repealing the provision just for a few companies would be equally unfair. Why should a company operating a wind farm be labeled a manufacturer, while one drilling for natural gas is not?

In case you’re wondering, Sununu voted against Ex-Im reauthorization in the House in 2002, and it passed the Senate by voice vote when he was there in 2006.

Related Content