Daily on Energy: Grid war games crash social media

SIGN UP! If you’d like to continue receiving Washington Examiner’s Daily on Energy newsletter, SUBSCRIBE HERE: http://newsletters.washingtonexaminer.com/newsletter/daily-on-energy/

GRID WAR GAMES CRASH SOCIAL MEDIA: A government exercise meant to test the nation’s response to attacks against the nation’s power grid had the most trouble, not from simulated hackers or bomb attacks, but from its massive stream of simulated newscasts, Facebook and Twitter feeds.

• Largest attack exercise: The utility industry’s grid security watchdog, the North American Electric Reliability Corporation, issued its first report on the GridEx IV exercise Friday, showing it to be its largest grid and infrastructure security event so far.

• Adding realism gets difficult: To add to the realism of the war games, the two-day event in November had its own simulated newscasts and social media feeds. It began including traditional and social media in its last GridEx event in 2015. But the expanded array of social media and tweets in last year’s exercise almost proved to be too much to handle, according to the report.

• Crashing the system: The problem stemmed from realistic newscasts competing for space on the same server with social media, which nearly broke the entire system.

The media platform was used to “imitate” social media, including Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, blogs, in addition to traditional media such as television, newspapers, and radio.

The platform began to buckle under the pressure of juggling both network news and social media.

• What did the attacks look like? “We give them an A-Team scenario” that makes it incredibly hard for utilities to cope with the level of attack, said Bill Lawrence, director of NERC’s Electricity Information Sharing and Analysis Center, on a Friday call.

• Describing the attacks: The newscasts and tweets began to flow on day one of the Nov. 15-16 exercise, in which unnamed “adversaries launched coordinated physical attacks at predetermined sites using vehicles to deliver explosive packages to damage and disable generation and transmission facilities.” Meanwhile, industry staff were seeing cyber attacks across the system.

• Fog of war: Lawrence suggested one of the functions of the social media component is to create the fog of war and escalate confusion. “We live in a world of social media that our adversaries can take advantage of” to “scare” and misinform the population, he said.

Welcome to Daily on Energy, compiled by Washington Examiner Energy and Environment Writers John Siciliano (@JohnDSiciliano) and Josh Siegel (@SiegelScribe). Email [email protected] for tips, suggestions, calendar items and anything else. If a friend sent this to you and you’d like to sign up, click here. If signing up doesn’t work, shoot us an email and we’ll add you to our list.

TRUMP URGED TO IMPOSE DEADLINE FOR FIXING ETHANOL MANDATE: The fight between the ethanol industry and independent refiners over the Environmental Protection Agency’s Renewable Fuel Standard won’t disappear over Congress’ two-week recess.

• Congress vs. Trump: Sources tell John that the new wrinkle in the talks is trying to find a way in which the White House and Congress can address the issue together, instead of against one another.

Congress doesn’t want the White House to act administratively, asking Trump to back off while they seek to fix the ethanol mandate with legislation.

Refiners than’t blend ethanol into the fuel supply say they are having to pay exorbitant prices for credits that allow them to abide by the Renewable Fuel Standard. But the ethanol industry says they shouldn’t be given a pass.

• Best to include White House: One source who has been talking to both congressional leaders and the administration says a path in which the White House plays a role in getting Congress to act would be best.

The source says there is “clearly a desire by the Trump administration to address the compliance costs” faced by refiners, while maintaining the president’s stated support for the ethanol industry.

• Hitting both goals: Achieving both goals is still best done through legislation, the sources tells John. But that being said, the difficulties of moving legislation are huge. That’s where Trump could be most effective by imposing a deadline.

• Deadline: The White House could give Congress until 2019 to act. If lawmakers do nothing, Trump could move on implementing measures to reduce the costs on refiners, while helping the ethanol industry blend more of its product into the fuel supply — the “win-win” plan offered by Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas.

• 99 counties of ethanol: Meanwhile, Iowa Republican Sen. Joni Ernst has made ethanol a key part of her 99-county tour of her home state during the recess.

The senator has been pushing back against Cruz’s proposal, which would upset demand for one of her state’s top exports — corn ethanol.

Trump is said to be weighing Cruz’s proposal to waive refiners’ obligations under the program to blend corn ethanol.  

Ernst tweeted that one of her first stops on the tour was a “productive visit to the Foundation Analytical Lab in Cherokee County to learn more about their work with ethanol plants around the country and important biofuel research.”

EPA POISED TO ANNOUNCE REJECTION OF OBAMA-ERA VEHICLE FUEL STANDARDS: The EPA is expected to formally declare Tuesday that stricter President Barack Obama-era fuel-efficiency rules for vehicles are “not appropriate.”

• Friendly territory: EPA Administrator Scott Pruitt plans to visit a Virginia Chevrolet dealership on Tuesday to make the announcement, according to Reuters and the New York Times. He must sign papers making his decision official by Sunday.

The EPA declined Friday to comment on Pruitt’s plans. An EPA spokesman said “a final determination will be signed by April 1.”

Automakers have asked for more flexibility to meet fuel-efficiency requirements, but are wary of a significant rollback that could spark a fight with California, which is allowed to have its own standards..

• Rejecting Obama: Pruitt is expected to say the Obama administration’s fuel-economy rules for cars and light-duty trucks, such as pickups and sport utility vehicles, must be revised for model years 2022 to 2025, although the agency won’t immediately propose new requirements. Obama’s standards would require automakers to nearly double the average fuel economy of new cars and trucks to 54.5 miles per gallon by 2025.

PJM BASHES FIRST ENERGY’S PLEA FOR PERRY TO SAVE COAL, NUCLEAR PLANTS: The grid operator that run’s America’s largest power market denounced a request from utility First Energy Thursday for an emergency order to save nuclear and coal power plants across the Midwest.

“This is not an issue of reliability,” PJM Interconnection said. “There is no immediate emergency.”

• Competitors fight back: The American Petroleum Institute, the largest lobbying group for the oil and natural gas industries, also slammed the request.

“FirstEnergy needs to stop misleading the public and government officials about the status of its power plants in Ohio and Pennsylvania,” it said. “FirstEnergy’s latest attempt to spread a false narrative surrounding the reliability of the electric grid is nothing more than a ruse that will force Main Street consumers to pay higher prices.”

• Crying for help: First Energy on Thursday requested the Energy Department approve an emergency order under section 202 of the Federal Power Act, which gives Energy Secretary Rick Perry the authority to direct the “temporary” continued use of power plants in circumstances that include war, energy shortages, or sudden surges in demand.

The utility filed its request after announcing Wednesday that it would close three nuclear power plants in Ohio and Pennsylvania over the next four years.

EXXON LOSES TO ATTORNEYS GENERAL IN CLIMATE COURT: New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman and his Democratic coalition scored a major victory against oil giant Exxon Mobil in federal district court in the Empire State Thursday.

The court ruled that Exxon’s claims in the case were “implausible.” The company had argued that the New York and Massachusetts attorneys general had conspired to violate its constitutional right to free speech about climate change.

Schneiderman had been leading an investigation into whether the company misinformed its shareholders and the public on the risks associated with global warming.

PRUITT PAID $50 PER NIGHT FOR CONDO CO-OWNED BY WIFE OF ENERGY LOBBYIST: Pruitt spent some of his first year in office living in a Washington townhouse that is co-owned by the wife of an energy lobbyist.

The lobbyist, J. Steven Hart, told ABC News, which broke the story, that Pruitt paid market rate for a condo in the townhouse near the Capitol.

But Bloomberg reported late Thursday that Pruitt paid $50 per night for a single bedroom, only paying on the nights he actually slept there. In all, Pruitt paid $6,100 to use the room for roughly six months.

Pruitt worked directly with Hart, the energy lobbyist, to arrange the deal, ABC News said in a new report Friday.

• Temporary arrangement: An EPA spokesman confirmed to the Washington Examiner that Pruitt occupied a bedroom in the condo.

“While transitioning to Washington, Administrator Pruitt signed a lease to rent a bedroom in a condo and he moved out at the end of July,” said spokesman Jahan Wilcox.

• ‘Routine business’: Justina Fugh, the EPA ethics counsel, says the living arrangement doesn’t violate ethics rules because Pruitt paid rent.

“I don’t conclude that this is a prohibited gift at all. It was a routine business transaction and permissible even if from a personal friend,” Fugh told Josh.

• EPA ties: Hart, the CEO of Williams and Jensen, has clients with business relevant to the EPA’s regulatory efforts, including Cheniere Energy Inc. and railroad company Norfolk Southern. Cheniere is the largest natural gas exporter in the U.S.

The firm also says it lobbies on issues related to the Clean Air Act, which the EPA administers.

WHY IS THE EPA CHIEF LOOKING TO EXPORT WESTERN COAL? Pruitt just discovered where 40 percent of the nation’s coal comes from: Beyond Appalachia in the Powder River Basin of Wyoming and Montana.

He was in Wyoming touring coal mines, and touting the low-sulfur, albeit lower energy density, of western coal, once touted as a way to reduce sulfur dioxide emissions that was a problem in burning coal from back east.

• Coal equals better air quality: “If we really care about our air quality, we’ll export Powder River Basin coal,” Pruitt said. “The reason you want to export Powder River Basin coal is because countries internationally are using coal from Indonesia and other places, and it’s not as good as it is here.

“We have to figure out a way to get this coal exported to countries. The demand is there. We’re working on that, as others are,” he said.

• Export Protection Agency: Pruitt said he is actively involved in looking at ways to work out problems facing coal exports. “We’ve got to get it worked out and we’re looking at all options. We’re on it.”

Pruitt spent his Thursday touring the Black Thunder coal mine, one of the largest in the country, with Wyoming Republican Sens. John Barrasso and Mike Enzi.

Pruitt came to declare “the war on coal is over,” according to the EPA.

• Coal country: Wyoming is the nation’s leading producer of coal. On Tuesday, the EPA hosted its final listening session in Gillette, Wyo., on its move to repeal the Obama-era Clean Power Plan, which would have required power plants to reduce carbon emissions.

CLIMATE CHANGE IS BIGGEST THREAT TO HUMANITY, UN CHIEF SAYS: Antonio Guterres, the United Nations secretary general, said Thursday that climate change is “the most systemic threat to humankind” and urged global leaders to reduce their countries’ greenhouse gas emissions.

• Pay Trump no mind: Guterres, speaking at UN headquarters in New York, downplayed the impact of the Trump administration’s decision to leave the Paris climate change agreement in 2020.

Sixteen states and Puerto Rico have pledged to uphold the targets the U.S. made in the Paris agreement to reduce carbon emissions by at least 26 percent by 2025.

“Independently of the position of the administration, the U.S. might be able to meet the commitments made in Paris as a country,” Guterres said. “And, as you know, all around the world, the role of governments is less and less relevant.”

RUNDOWN

Wall Street Journal How Tillerson’s Exxon designed an oil deal to skirt anticorruption scrutiny

New York Times Brazilian auction draws oil companies back to offshore drilling

Associated Press Advocacy group: Exxon knew of corruption in oil deal

Oilprice.com An energy crisis in looming in Southeast Europe

Washington Post The Sahara is growing, thanks in part to climate change

New York Times Tesla looked like the future. Now some ask if it has one

ADVERTISEMENT
<#include ‘/global/Live Intent Ads/WEX DoE Inline 1’>

Calendar

FRIDAY, MARCH 30

Congress is out until April 9.

10:30 a.m., Webinar. The North American Electric Reliability Corporation will present lessons learned from its fourth grid security exercise, GridEx IV, in November with more than 450 organizations from across North America participating.

cc.readytalk.com/r/ijato1cruaw6&eom      

MONDAY, APRIL 2

9 a.m.,  2703 Martin Luther King Jr. Ave. SE. State Department holds a meeting of the Shipping Coordination Committee to prepare for the 72nd session of the International Maritime Organization’s Marine Environment Protection Committee to be held at the IMO Headquarters in the United Kingdom on April 9-13.

9 a.m., 1 Veterans Place, Spring Room, Silver Spring, Md. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration holds a meeting of the Advisory Committee on Commercial Remote Sensing to receive updates on NOAA’s Commercial Remote Sensing Regulatory Affairs activities, discuss updates to the commercial remote sensing regulatory regime, and discuss updates in the regulations and new technological activities in space.

noaa.gov

TUESDAY, APRIL 3

9:30 a.m., 888 First St. NE. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission holds a meeting to discuss issues related to the coordination of affected systems raised in the complaint filed by EDF Renewable Energy against Midcontinent Independent System Operator, Southwest Power Pool, Inc and PJM Interconnection, and the commission’s Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on the generator interconnection process, April 3-4.

ferc.gov/whats-new/registration/04-03-18-form.asp

11 a.m., 500 E St. SW. International Trade Commission holds a meeting to vote on issues related to biodiesel from Argentina and Indonesia, and is scheduled to complete and file its determinations and views of the Commission by April 16.

itc.gov

8:30 a.m.,  2415 Eisenhower Ave., Room 2030, Alexandria, Va. National Science Foundation holds a meeting of the Advisory Committee for Biological Sciences.

nsf.gov

WEDNESDAY, APRIL 4

9 a.m., 1849 C St. NW. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service holds a meeting of the Sport Fishing and Boating Partnership Council, April 4-5.

fws.gov

9 a.m.,  419 Dirksen. Energy Department holds a meeting of the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission on “China’s Relations with U.S. Allies and Partners in Europe and the Asia Pacific.”

uscc.gov

Related Content