KING 5 Retracts Story on Washington State Shooter (Updated)

RETRACTION: The following post was based on an erroneous news report from KING 5 television. Arcen Cetin is in fact a United States citizen.

Arcen Cetin, the Turkish 20-year-old who is accused of murdering five strangers at a mall in Washington state last weekend, is not a U.S. citizen. But that doesn’t mean he hasn’t been voting in U.S. elections. KING 5, a Seattle television station, has the story:

Federal sources confirm to KING 5 that Cetin was not a U.S. citizen, meaning legally he cannot vote. However, state records show Cetin registered to vote in 2014 and participated in three election cycles, including the May presidential primary. Cetin, who immigrated to the United States from Turkey as a child, is considered a permanent resident or green card holder. While a permanent resident can apply for U.S. citizenship after a certain period of time, sources tell KING his status had not changed from green card holder to U.S. citizen. While voters must attest to citizenship upon registering online or registering to vote at the Department of Licensing Office, Washington state doesn’t require proof of citizenship. Therefore elections officials say the state’s elections system operates, more or less, under an honor system.

Meanwhile—despite the incessant drumbeat telling us there has never in the history of the Republic been a case of voter fraud—research published in Electoral Studies has found that non-citizens vote in significant enough numbers to actually sway elections. Yet liberal groups oppose states requiring proof of citizenship to vote. Their argument is that it’s better to err on the side of enfranchising more people. These laws “[exclude] legitimate voters who do not have documentary proof of citizenship,” they say. But at what cost?

Hillary Clinton, for her part, recently suggested that there is a “right” to immigrate to the United States—a remarkably radical position that no other U.S. president has ever held. (And perhaps needless to say, no other country in the world—save, perhaps, Angela Merkel’s Germany—takes the view that the world has a “right” to immigrate to their shores.) Do Clinton and her allies also believe foreigners have a “right” to vote in U.S. elections?

Related Content