Study: Liberal college students are sexist

RateMyProfessors.com is a popular site for rating professors and gaining insight on which professors to take, or not to take. A recent study also shows though that it may reflect sexism in college students.

As Inside Higher Ed pointed out, since 2006 the the site has reflected that students give the best reviews to professors who are seen as easy graders or good looking. This does not seem so surprising.

More recent studies are problematic in other ways, however. An study just published by PLOS One shows that “brilliant” and “genius” are more likely to describe male professors. The journal also reflects that “The Frequency of “Brilliant” and “Genius” in Teaching Evaluations Predicts the Representation of Women and African Americans across Fields.”

What fields received such compliments is also reflective. The introduction of the study notes:

Although many factors are undoubtedly at play, a recent proposal suggests that the fields in which women and African Americans are underrepresented (e.g., physics, philosophy) are those fields whose members believe that a spark of brilliance is required for success. The belief in the importance of untutored genius may be detrimental to the involvement of women and African Americans because of broad cultural stereotypes that portray the intellectual abilities of these groups in a negative light.

Because the comments are “spontaneous,” Andrei Cimpian who is a psychology professor at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and a co-author of the paper says they provide “an unvarnished reflection” of what people actually think.

The present research also mentions the idea of spontaneity. And, in the discussion it is mentioned:

Yet, the frequency with which these students spontaneously commented on whether their instructors were “brilliant” and “geniuses” tracked not only academics’ own beliefs about the importance of these traits but also the magnitude of gender and race gaps across much of academia.

The study is also similar to one from January 2015, which Cimpian also contributed to. The study noted “Expectations of brilliance underlie gender distributions across academic disciplines.”

College student lean overwhelmingly liberal/progressive according to all major polls, but this study would seem to indicate that these students may not be as forward-thinking as they project.

Related Content