Syracuse to students: Christmas tree “would not be inclusive”

Published December 11, 2015 4:26am ET



Syracuse University is joining other colleges waging the “War on Christmas.” The Daily Orange published a letter to the editor on Dec. 10 from freshman Aodhan Doyle asking about the school’s policy on holiday decorations. It’s impossible not to sympathize with Doyle, who just wanted to put up a Christmas tree and decorations in his dorm.

Doyle is quick to call out the school by writing how “there is clear hypocrisy in holiday celebrations at SU.” The residents who wanted the Christmas tree, which Doyle says is a majority, were denied because the RD said it “would not be inclusive” to other religions. Not only was the tree denied, but the one in the dining center, which also contained other decorations, was taken down on Dec. 8, as Doyle explains.

And, that’s not even where the hypocrisy is most in play.

While a Christmas tree was denied, a menorah was placed in a dorm, with a candle lighting taking place every night of Hanukkah. An e-mail was even sent out which actually encouraged the celebration of a religious holiday from the RD who wrote, “We hope this will be a great way for those celebrating the Jewish holiday to enjoy the tradition together, but the lightings are open to all residents.”

Doyle is not against Hanukah, and neither is this article. But as he says it best:

For a school/residence hall that is clearly trying to distance itself from associating with any specific holiday, as was demonstrated when our tree proposal was rejected, why is it okay to have a school sponsored Hanukkah celebration? In fact, if opening up the ceremony to all residents passes as “inclusive,” how doesn’t our proposal? Also, due to the fire code, residents who wish to light a menorah have been told to do so in the lounge, not in their room. That is understandable, no one wants a fire. But to allow the lighting of menorahs in the lounge, in an area where everyone is supposed to feel “inclusive,” but not the decorating of a Christmas tree, is hypocritical. I’m not waging war on Hanukkah; I just question why it’s okay for Syracuse to accept the celebration of some holidays in its buildings but not others.

It’s even more of a shame that one would be denied when Doyle mentions wishes for how “if I were able to put up a Christmas tree in the lounge, my Jewish friends would put a menorah right beside it.” Syracuse is not only engaging in the War on Christmas then, but ruining the holiday hopes of a young man who believes “what the holiday season is all about [is] celebrating together with those around us.”