A “quarterback controversy” suggests much depends on the choice. By that standard, Rex Grossman vs. John Beck might not measure up. What are the Redskins’ quarterback controversies that really mattered? 5. Patrick Ramsey vs. Shane Matthews vs. Danny Wuerffel » Ramsey was the first-round draft choice of the Redskins in 2002, but it was Steve Spurrier’s first season in Washington, and he was more comfortable with his former Florida quarterbacks — Matthews and Wuerffel.
4. Jeff George vs. Brad Johnson » George had a great arm. Johnson didn’t. But George went 1-6 as a starter in two seasons in Washington. Johnson went 17-10 before leading Tampa Bay to the 2002 Super Bowl title.
3. Heath Shuler vs. Gus Frerotte?» In the 1994 draft, Shuler was the third pick and Frerotte was the 197th. But Frerotte consistently outplayed Shuler and lasted five years in D.C., two more than Shuler.
2. Jay Schroeder vs. Doug Williams » Schroeder was younger, golden-armed and aloof. Williams was erratic but had a huge arm and heart, winning over fans and teammates. Coach Joe Gibbs had the right man in charge — Williams — when the Redskins dominated the Broncos 42-10 in Super Bowl XXII.
1. Sonny Jurgensen vs. Billy Kilmer » Jurgensen was in the twilight of his Hall of Fame career but still was one of the best passers in the game. But coach George Allen favored Kilmer, a journeyman and game manager, to execute his notoriously conservative game plans. Fans registered their opinion with “I Like Billy” and “I Like Sonny” bumper stickers.
– Kevin Dunleavy
