Clausen shouldn’t be first-round option

Published February 15, 2010 5:00am ET



If the Redskins want to draft a quarterback with the fourth overall pick, they’d better hope Sam Bradford is still available. Especially if they desire Notre Dame’s Jimmy Clausen, says one former college scout for an NFL team. And he’s not alone: more and more, analysts peg him as a guy who should not be drafted in the top 10.

The former college scout said Clausen would be a good choice for the Redskins — with the 36th overall pick. The big problem he has with Clausen? He predicted that Clausen will measure shorter at the scouting combine than his listed height of 6-foot-3; this scout predicted he’ll be closer in size to Drew Brees, who is a shade under 6-feet. It also doesn’t help Clausen’s case that he had a poor record as a starter and did not beat a ranked opponent in his time at Notre Dame. The scout also said that Brady Quinn was a more attractive candidate because of his intelligence, size — he’s just bigger than Clausen — and character. Yet he wasn’t drafted until the 22nd pick in the first round. So why would Clausen go higher?

That said, there is a lot to like about Clausen, who improved his decision-making and accuracy this season.

After watching more film of Clausen the other day, the scout said, “He showed a very strong command of their offensive system, as well as outstanding poise and toughness in his play. He is a very good overall athlete for the position.”

He likes that he is quick enough to slide within the pocket and roll away from pressure to buy more time — like Brees. Clausen, though, is not a “special athlete who can threaten a defense with his legs. He is an undersized passer with very good mobility.”

Clausen has excellent passing mechanics and did a nice job carrying out fakes and running play-action. He also has a quick release and a tight delivery without wasted motion and good arm strength.

“He can throw with both excellent touch and accuracy,” the scout said.

In time, Clausen could prove to be a good quarterback. But it’s why he should not be taken in the top 10; maybe not even in the first round. However, if Washington gets him with its second-round pick, it could prove to be a smart choice.

Follow me on twitter @John_Keim