Texas Gov. Rick Perry plans to unveil his fiscal and economic plan today in hopes of reviving his candidacy. I’ll have more to say once I see more details, but I have a few initial thoughts based on what he’s already outlined in a Wall Street Journal op-ed.
To start with, Perry’s proposed flat tax isn’t all that flat. One problem is that it’s optional, meaning that taxpayers would have the choice between remaining in the current tax code, or filing under a new “flat tax” with a 20 percent rate. Making it optional is a nod to the political reality that it would be harder to impose a flat tax immediately, because so many people have planned their lives assuming the various deductions in the tax code exist. From a policy perspective, it’s thorny though. We’d still be stuck with a bloated tax code that people could exploit, and nobody who benefits from it would be inclined to switch. It would also make it difficult to score from a budgetary standpoint, because it’s hard to predict how many people would choose each system. Though it’s a complicated idea, it isn’t totally unprecedented. Rep. Paul Ryan’s original “Roadmap for America’s Future,” which was highly touted by many conservatives, also made its proposed “flatter” tax optional.