Beware of simple prescriptions for GOP

Published



In the past week, there has been a flood of commentary diagnosing the problems with the Republican Party and offering simple solutions for how they could be resolved. These advice pieces can generally be boiled down to “Republicans would be more successful if they agreed with me on more issues.” Predictably, moderates have argued the party needs to be more centrist, while conservatives have argued it needs to be more faithful to conservative values. Socially liberal Republicans have blamed social conservatives for the results while those who have been pushing for a path to citizenship for years have blamed immigration hardliners. But the reality is a lot more complicated.

For instance, consider the idea that a softer line on immigration will boost Republicans’ electoral prospects by helping win over Hispanic voters. There’s no doubt that Republicans will have to find a way to improve their standing among this growing demographic group to compete in national elections. But it isn’t necessarily clear that immigration is the answer. According to a Pew Hispanic Center survey released in October, just 34 percent of Latino registered voters considered immigration to be “extremely important” to them. That trailed education (55 percent); jobs and the economy (54 percent); health care (50 percent); the federal budget deficit (36 percent) and barely edged out taxes (33 percent). It’s quite possible, in other words, that Republicans could back some form of amnesty for illegal immigrants, and still find that they don’t improve among this voting bloc. Also, a softer line on immigration could hurt Republicans’ ability to win over working class voters who feel threatened by cheaper labor, and working class voters are a bloc that another contingent of pundits views as crucial to GOP comeback chances.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.